Ableton Forum

Dumbest thread ever, couldn't be assed to read it, and I'll be dammed if I'm going to join in on an argument that's been DEAD for almost 100 years. Classical music long ago accepted ATONAL NOISE, recordings, sound FX and other non tonal AUDIO as music, realized they had to eschew normal tabulator f...

the fact one says "uhm, i am not convinced" does not mean "you believe in your own BS". It simply means: "your argumentations are not strong enough to make me change my mind". Here, for instance, no-one has been able to give clear answers to my questions. One, above al...

I know it is (a cool story). For instance, can you answer those questions?...

the fact one says "uhm, i am not convinced" does not mean "you believe in your own BS". It simply means: "your argumentations are not strong enough to make me change my mind". Here, for instance, no-one has been able to give clear answers to my questions. One, above all...

that is what i said to stringtapper. He believes in all those weird theories about "timbre"... But i asked why loopstationzebra laughed at my "you have two different compositions".

why the guy laughed? I looked for "you have two different compositions" in the google translator, but there are no idioms etc. Why is it funny?

http://youtu.be/EaKWHvUASgk

does the vitiligo transform audio into midi?

LoopStationZebra wrote:

9V wrote: you have two different compositions

is it not correct in english? Is it something funny?

You are the one insisting on the stipulation that musical parameters must have "symbols" attached to them in order to be musical parameters. One need only to look to any musical culture that transmits its music through oral tradition to see that symbols and notation are not a requirement ...

no, for me that is not music, but sound. You call those max experiments and the other 0,001% "music". For me music is tonal music, not "timbre" modifications. Again, your mistake is that you believe "timbre" is a musical parameter. It isn't (infact you cannot even &quo...

no, OSC (not "audio"). :roll: As an acronym of "open sound control" (via TCP/IP) not as "oscillator"... No, Max can control audio signals with other audio signals making it possible to sequence music using audio only, no MIDI and no OSC. as i wrote before, for me that ...

no, OSC (not "audio"). As an acronym of "open sound control" (via TCP/IP) not as "oscillator"...

no, for me that is not music, but sound. You call those max experiments and the other 0,001% "music". For me music is tonal music, not "timbre" modifications. Again, your mistake is that you believe "timbre" is a musical parameter. It isn't (infact you cannot even "...