Ableton Forum

Well, we can obviously only comment on what we experienced in the past and that is neglect of Live for the benefit of the not so smooth integration of M4L. Maybe the future will bring all of what you wrote, you seem to be very sure of it. I guess you must have special insider knowledge since your v...

Have you mistakenly mixed up the tabs in your browser, or do you really view the Live forums as your personal blog?!

Btw: you are rambling incoherently

Well, we can obviously only comment on what we experienced in the past and that is neglect of Live for the benefit of the not so smooth integration of M4L. Maybe the future will bring all of what you wrote, you seem to be very sure of it. I guess you must have special insider knowledge since your vi...

And how would you interact with the rate or the amplitude of the oscillation in a live situation?! Oh yeah live manipulation would deaden that approach. Unless, of course, you resigned yourself to live (life) largely consisting of a limited number of predeterministic events and possible moves; and ...

This thinking is exactly why I'm afraid of this buy out, because I fear many at Ableton share it. No a M4L LFO is not a good substitute for a native one at least until: 1.) Assigning the LFO to a parameter in Live does not limit me from modulating it via other means like with a controller or automa...

I even mentioned the LFO in my post Just out of curiosity, aren't short-length unlinked automation clips (better than) the device-independent native LFOs you seek? /ducks /fastens seatbelt /raises blast doors And how would you interact with the rate or the amplitude of the oscillation in a live sit...

Could you please give me an example of an essential native device that's missing? I must know! Are you for real?! I even mentioned the LFO in my post :roll: And if you are now planning to go on a tired rant about how a LFO is not essential, I'll simply point out that neither M4L nor Live itself is ...

No sorry, if M4L hadn't been used so much to excuse not giving new (essential!) native devices... Could you please give me an example of an essential native device that's missing? I must know! Are you for real?! I even mentioned the LFO in my post :roll: And if you are now planning to go on a tired...

Ableton could be a context where people can make use of it, be exposed to it, construct it. From Ableton’s side, Max has always been a thing that’s been used to prototype stuff [at Ableton]. And our hope is that if transformation into these larger, newer contexts is a big part of what needs to happ...

Yay, that sounds wonderful... /someone, not me

I don't think that's possible

Anyway don't worry I've been all over this question and I think what I'm asking for is not possible Lol, no :lol: You're just asking in a way that makes it really hard to help you. But your clarification at least made clear that you are an absolute beginner. I will keep that in mind now. It's maybe...

yep

https://forum.ableton.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=165616 https://forum.ableton.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=222655 https://forum.ableton.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=137486 It`s an old one. Discussed and suggested in almost all the ways we have. And - sorry guys - M4L might be a tool, but not the sol...