Mesmer wrote:Ideal case: it has "most" of the features I like about Live, without none of the bloat
Less than Ideal case: it has "some" of the features I like, and I can live without the others I would have liked ("drumracks"..). It's a nice compromise
Worst case: It's so limited, there's no reason to get it.
Yeah, it needs to have enough to use say the puremagnetic paks without having them limited. I was all keen on getting their Amp Pak, but it has limited function if you are on LE.
The track count thing is fine, but LE limits its own use with no rewire and and no midi out to ext devices.
There has been lots said about how people don't want Live to become yet another 'same old, same old' DAW. But the fact is there are lots of people who don't have the freight to buy full versions of 2-3 DAWs just to use certain features.
I am looking to upgrade my scoring/notation software because thats what I use nearly every working day. Logic Express 8 has Rewire AND Scoring and so could be a perfect candidate to partner with Live LE. But Live LE won't allow it. I am not flush with cash to buy the full version of Live and have to think about an either, or, type of choice. Its a shame really. I am sure there is a whole layer of users who wouldn't think twice about paying for LE version updates, even if its barely used, because it offers some uniqueness of musical expression. Plus, if it remains a usable and friendly option or go to tool in conjunction with other tools then its presence amoung the other options is always fresh.
I often get the feeling that this forums user base at times only reflects a more or less advanced type of user. Users of the full version are often unfamiliar with LE's limitations and so do not give appropriate advice. There is no LE user forum or any LE guru's around here. Its like the Abe's don't really think that there would be people who actually only really want to use and master LE. Its like they have not given very much thought to how well they could hook customers with the LE version. The whole entry level thing.
These would be my inclusions for 8 LE
I think the track counts are fine.
The number of Audio inputs and out puts could be increased to 4 each at least
Same with the Internal and External AU/VST's and effects.
Some Drum Rack presence, with editing.
Increase the number of send and return tracks to at least 4
Enable Track Freeze (for all of the entry level users with aging computers)
Enable midi out put to hardware synths (perhaps cap the number to 2-3)
Enable Midi clock/sync
Enable Rewire.
Video stuff can be left out.
I think the new Looper should be included as well, even if it has some limitations imposed.
These things would make a great 8 LE and surely cement my attention for a long time to come.