HELP! USB OR FIREWIRE SOUNDCARD
-
- Posts: 21
- Joined: Tue Nov 04, 2008 3:33 pm
- Location: ITALY
HELP! USB OR FIREWIRE SOUNDCARD
Can anybody tell me which one is better mixing with Live and the reason why would you say that?
Thanx in advance.
Thanx in advance.
Federico Caiulo
Model: MacBook 13”
OS: 10.4.11
CPU: 2 GHz Core 2 Duo
Memory: 2GB (2 X 1GB)
Running Live! 6.0.7 with UC-33e USB/MIDI CONTROLLER
Model: MacBook 13”
OS: 10.4.11
CPU: 2 GHz Core 2 Duo
Memory: 2GB (2 X 1GB)
Running Live! 6.0.7 with UC-33e USB/MIDI CONTROLLER
-
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Sun May 04, 2008 5:18 pm
Everybody is wrong.
In theory Firewire is king - but it all comes down to what kind of firewire controller chip you have in your computer. In my laptop (Dell - shivers!) I got Ricoh = the suck = an USB 1 audio interface can run circles around my firewire interface.
Check out your controller. As far as I've heard, the controllers made by Texas Instruments are the ones working best.
In theory Firewire is king - but it all comes down to what kind of firewire controller chip you have in your computer. In my laptop (Dell - shivers!) I got Ricoh = the suck = an USB 1 audio interface can run circles around my firewire interface.
Check out your controller. As far as I've heard, the controllers made by Texas Instruments are the ones working best.
the question should not be which performs better, but rather which one will survive.
i have a white macbook with firewire that gets slowly old. so i suppose, it will need to be upgraded this year sometime. i dont feel like buying a MBP. but also, psychologically, just cant bring myself to buy a USB interface. it's not because i know for sure it's less good.
it's a tough decision. especially if you throw 500 bucks on something you like to keep longer than a year. .
and.. USB 3 is coming in a year or two.....
i have a white macbook with firewire that gets slowly old. so i suppose, it will need to be upgraded this year sometime. i dont feel like buying a MBP. but also, psychologically, just cant bring myself to buy a USB interface. it's not because i know for sure it's less good.
it's a tough decision. especially if you throw 500 bucks on something you like to keep longer than a year. .
and.. USB 3 is coming in a year or two.....
Last edited by shai on Sat Feb 07, 2009 11:06 am, edited 1 time in total.
Everybody's wrong because you bought a Dell with a ricoh chip in it ?Carl Lofgren wrote:Everybody is wrong.
TI's are best but the new agere chips seem to be working on the new macbook/pro.
Judging by the OS on that Macbook it most probably has a TI chip, when Tiger was shipping they were mostly TI.
-
- Posts: 63
- Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 11:59 am
- Location: Aboard the mining ship Red Dwarf
-
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Sun May 04, 2008 5:18 pm
How you can interpret my words like that is beyond me.beatpoet wrote:Everybody's wrong because you bought a Dell with a ricoh chip in it ?Carl Lofgren wrote:Everybody is wrong.
If somebody is recommending firewire without first checking out what firewire controller their computer is using, then yes. That is wrong.
A computer with a good firewire controller = lovely
A computer with a bad firewire controller = horror
Do you understand me better now?
-
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Sun May 04, 2008 5:18 pm
That would be mainly PC laptops. Desktops are a different story, especially if you are building one yourself. My PC desktop has 3 bus powered (6 pin) FW400 connections.Arnold-Rimmer wrote:... but what put me off firewire is that Windows machines don't have bus powered interfaces, whereas for USB they do.
-
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:16 pm
- Location: uk SW
True, but for a desktop you would be much better off getting a PCI card with a breakout box.gjm wrote:That would be mainly PC laptops. Desktops are a different story, especially if you are building one yourself. My PC desktop has 3 bus powered (6 pin) FW400 connections.Arnold-Rimmer wrote:... but what put me off firewire is that Windows machines don't have bus powered interfaces, whereas for USB they do.
Why?Da hand wrote:True, but for a desktop you would be much better off getting a PCI card with a breakout box.gjm wrote:That would be mainly PC laptops. Desktops are a different story, especially if you are building one yourself. My PC desktop has 3 bus powered (6 pin) FW400 connections.Arnold-Rimmer wrote:... but what put me off firewire is that Windows machines don't have bus powered interfaces, whereas for USB they do.