PD vs Max/MSP/Jitter for visuals?

Discussion of music production, audio, equipment and any related topics, either with or without Ableton Live
last man on earth
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Nov 11, 2007 1:31 am
Location: USA

Re: PD vs Max/MSP/Jitter for visuals?

Post by last man on earth » Thu Jun 18, 2009 1:59 pm

gpvillamil wrote:Well, PD is free, so the question is whether or not you want to buy Max/MSP/Jitter, isn't it?

PD, as a programming language, is more developed than Max: data structures stand out as a particular difference.

However, as a development environment, Max 5 is definitely smoother and easier - it feels a lot more modern.

Jitter's main advantage over GEM is the years of development, and the documentation. Also somewhat better for working with OpenGL and shaders, though this is changing.

Max has a number of extensions, like the Max Toolbar or Jamoma, that go a long way to shortening the learning curve.

I would go ahead and get Max, since you can get a student price. Learn Max using all the various tutorials and the great documentation. Then, get PD and spend some time exploring the differences. You might find that you'll want to use PD for specific projects, maybe based on things like the visual data structures it supports.
This is the conclusion that I am coming to as well.

I just got up, so I'm going to check those vids you guys posted in a bit, but I forgot to mention earlier that I'm pretty much all mac, so VVVV is unfortunately out of the question - I'll edit the first post to reflect that. It's a shame too, I was looking at V4 prior to starting this thread and spent about an hour just checking out different stuff on their website before I started realizing that I saw no Mac references, then I check the compatibility page, Windows only. It really would be quite the contender if I ran windows.

Anyway, I'd still like to see examples of visuals of either M/M/J or PD/G if you guys have them - I'd love to see what everyone has going on, for sure, and thank you guys for the advice/vids so far!

scientist
Posts: 1336
Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2003 2:06 am
Location: seattle

Re: PD vs Max/MSP/Jitter for visuals?

Post by scientist » Thu Jun 18, 2009 5:17 pm

processing is worth a look.

http://www.vimeo.com/2577870
(and click the 'processing.org' tag from there)

i knew absolutely nothing about code, and have been fiddling with processing a bit. once you get the basic syntax down, its relatively easy to dig through other people's code to understand what it does. from there it becomes pretty easy to cut and paste to develop your own stuff. while it can do video manipulation, my guess is its strong point above other apps is its generative/"drawing" abilities.

Post Reply