Logic Studio 9 vs Ableton live 8 Suite

[felipescalador12]

well.. since I didnt find any threats that cover this.

I decided to make one.

Also because I am between this two...

just want to know what you think

Which one is best for electronic music production??
sequencing???
Live use??
Recording??
etc...

[Tarekith]

No need to make threats man.

[marcoskohler]

I've always used Live, but my school has the new Logic Studio for $150, so I bought it. I don't do electronic/live stuff. The mere fact that Logic 9 let's me apply Bezier curves to any automation has made my mix sound much more fluid and natural. I like it so far.

[Sage]

well.. since I didnt find any threats that cover this.

I decided to make one.

Also because I am between this two...

just want to know what you think

Which one is best for electronic music production??
sequencing???
Live use??
Recording??
etc...

Electronic production = Live
Live use = Live (Never witnessed anyone using Logic live for anything other than as a backing track, whereas Live is designed as a performance tool)
Recording = Logic

[timothyallan]

I'm going to jump out on a limb here and say that Live is better for live performances.

Let me make you a spreadsheet for the rest of your points quickly:

Live - Can record
Logic - Can record

Live - Can sequence
Logic - Can sequence

Live - Can make electronic music
Logic - Can make electronic music

Hope that helps??

[sparklepuff]

Logic is 1 better.

[felipescalador12]

No need to make threats man.

haha yes. my english is not very good haha

[Illum]

Anything involving video or music notation-Logic
Everything else-Live

[starving student]

what artist are your influences?

[felipescalador12]

what artist are your influences?

Assuming that question is for me..

I like The prodigy
Scotter
Paul van dyk
I also like hot chip

[Homebelly]

what artist are your influences?

Are they professionals

[tacvbo83]

Maaaaaaaaaaaaan! Where the bafthroom at?

[starving student]

what artist are your influences?

Assuming that question is for me..

I like The prodigy
Scotter
Paul van dyk
I also like hot chip

I suggest Live for it's flexibility and creativity inducing design, so many ways to flip the music and even if you end up using logic later you'll still appreciate how much live can inspire you and spark alot of ideas

[sacredgeometry]

Live use = Live (Never witnessed anyone using Logic live for anything other than as a backing track, whereas Live is designed as a performance tool)

simon posford uses logic with shpongle for his live shows, although i think he will be using live soon

[sacredgeometry]

Anything involving video or music notation-Logic
Everything else-Live

i agree, working with film or instrumental artists (bands) its pro tools or logic land for me

everything else is live ....which is 90-99% of the time