DrXparaMental wrote:
What I mean by "apathy" is the stance that many legitimate US citizens take on the issue. They just don't give a shit and go on about how we have so many worse problems, yet take no real issue with those problems either. The expressed ploy that "we have much bigger fish to fry" is fine as long as you are busy frying bigger fish. Excuses like that are typically used by people that are (a) afraid to make their views known, sometimes even to themselves, or (b) They're just apathetic slugs by nature that don't give a shit about much of anything. Caught up in the the vacuum of their own pseudo contentment.
I don't have one personal thing against illegal immigrants in terms of their individual humanity. ESPECIALLY with respect to different races of human beings, one over the other. I don't blame them for "taking the bait". If this were a perfect world we would all live under one flag called Earth. But that's not reality is it? To me, the self supporting lower middle class working man, the illegal immigration problem is real. I see what it has done to the non union private contractor, skilled trade jobs sector. Illegals are like potato bugs. Ravaging a staple crop while not doing so out of some diabolical evil intent, but rather out of basic necessity to themselves as a result of mismanagement of the private sector. Shit government basically. But remember, if we can't logically blame them for "taking the bait", logical turn about would seem to dictate that we can't blame the contractor for "taking the bait". I blame both equally. But mostly I blame apathy and covert divisive politics for being the largest and most powerful enabler of all.
I promised myself that I wouldn't get into these impotent debates, but I am FAIL, so wtf. But I ask, what do you seek? what is your proposal. How do we fry these "small fish."
You've enumerated the types or classes of apathy, which to you are the ones who don't share your outrage at the situation as concerns illegal immigration. You haven't offered what one is suppose to do beyond this outrage. Do You think forum fingerpecking is a viable and productive expression?
I've been watching a lot of townhall meetings lately, most seem to have taken place in the south. At one meeting , a rep barely brought up the word immigrant before people started shouting kill em', shoot them at the border, etc. You realize as you may classify me as apathetic, I initially group you in with these newly emerging townhall types. Right or wrong, it's in essence, exactly what you are doing. Without an actual proposal that extends beyond outrage, your case becomes cartoonish.
I live about 40 miles from the Mexican border. The Hispanic population is great enough to render this area Mexico, part two. Now, if you took one of those townhall right-wing groupies and brought them here. What would they think? They would see each and every Hispanic and gloss over all objectivity and yell, "SHOOT EM" ALL!"
You say above that you have nothing against "personal humanity" of the "illegal immigrant." If so, then why don't you spend your energies trying to come up with a solution. Your way, now, leads to attacks against their "personal humanity." I would say your outrage if not apathetic only simmers down to the pathetic.
Now, contrary to what you probably think, I hold some resentment. Where i live it is almost essential to know Spanish to get a blue collar job. Some jobs require this outright. But if I yell in the streets my voice will be added to the wave of psychotics yelling "shoot em," a group I despise beyond expression. So my non-action on the issue is not a case of apathy, but one of sobriety.
Now, woo-hoo, Live 8 rocks. Making music, that's where I'm starting to show signs of apathy.