Song sounds perfect in ableton but exported it sounds bad ):

Discuss music production with Ableton Live.
maky355
Posts: 238
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2011 6:10 am

Re: Song sounds perfect in ableton but exported it sounds bad ):

Post by maky355 » Tue May 07, 2019 3:48 pm

This thread is full of serious like really serious completely wrong information. I don't know cause of OP issue. I never heard for this. It can be something so trivial as having enabled Acoustic Effects in operating system itself so when he is listening his audio file it is sounding bad/different because it's been processed on playback. I know some Realtek onboard audio cards and their lame software enable some Virtual acoustic FX. But in any way:

- No your soundcard driver doesn't render your audio. Your DAW does that. Live in this case. I can assure you that. Changing from ASIO4ALL to another type of ASIO or whatever will not solve your problems (if there is really a problem).
- Changin or ticking "Normalize" on export most DEFINITELY won't solve your problem. Actually don't do it. You say you know Mastering so i don't have to explain you why you do not enable that option. Especially if you used compression or limiter on your Master channel.
- Switching your computer from one version to Apple also won't solve your issue. In fact it may be so if you have wrong audio set up on Windows but that's your fault not Windows fault.
- switching bit depth also should not yield any drastically different audible result.
- and yes ASIO4ALL is most definitely ASIO driver no matter what some users here proposed about it. And it's a good one if your audio card vendor doesn't have a proper one (it can happen). Not only it's adequate but it can daisy chain two audio cards like on Mac computers.

Basically your export settings are fine.

I propose this.

Add simple kick from Ableton Live default library. Any. Add 4 notes (for the floor pattern) and 8 bars long. Save that project. Upload it here. So we all can open it.

In the meantime Export your audio file from that VERY same project. It should be really small size. Upload it here. Only THEN we can compare and tell you does your ableton really export something different then it should be.

On top of that report us - does that very same 8 bar session also sounds different when exported then in Ableton playback?

Cheers

ToniStar
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2024 6:32 pm

Re: Song sounds perfect in ableton but exported it sounds bad ):

Post by ToniStar » Mon Jan 15, 2024 6:41 pm

Im been reading this lately a lot. I have recorded about 2 years now and about 50 songs with audacity and 30 songs with Ableton. I like ableton a lot however the export quality is horrible. Half of the reverb is gone. Tone clearity and punctuality is gone. Tried the reverb coming with Ableton and same problem. I use LX480 for reverb as a alternate option.

Im engineer too and very anal about technology. I have headphones worth more than a thousand euros with great amp. I have quality setup by heart. Had all the time the same setup, listening from same player with same settings.

What I did I set recording to from another software to line and recorded the output of Ableton. Made the export from another software which took less than five seconds and BOOM ! I nice quality again.

Please Ableton, fix this horrible export quality problem. Period. I dont get how people get offended and tell there is no problems. Buy a set of ears for god sake ;)

Have a nice recordings you all !

Toni

ToniStar
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2024 6:32 pm

Re: Song sounds perfect in ableton but exported it sounds bad ):

Post by ToniStar » Thu Jan 18, 2024 5:53 pm

Had a mono button on the export page. I cannot believe how I could put it on.

Filesize grew from 17mb -> 49mb on one recording 4min length

Now its a lot better! even almost good as from the DAW

slow.robot
Posts: 196
Joined: Thu Feb 18, 2021 2:06 am

Re: Song sounds perfect in ableton but exported it sounds bad ):

Post by slow.robot » Thu Jan 18, 2024 6:17 pm

more often than not, PEBKAC 😅

Post Reply