Export MIDI issue

[8E]

I meant that a potentially better way to move MIDI into another DAW is to send it out over the MIDI bus and record the MIDI directly into the other DAW when in sync. This will maintain minute timing. To be able to do this requires a good set up (and both DAWs obviously), but when needed it beats exporting.

MIDI Exports as they are now are limited to 96ppq. I think that's too crude for resolution, at least of you record MIDI from live performances, which I do.

Hm, that is indeed very interesting. I did routing ages ago, I might try it again.
If I may know, what is "ppq"?

[Stromkraft]

I meant that a potentially better way to move MIDI into another DAW is to send it out over the MIDI bus and record the MIDI directly into the other DAW when in sync. This will maintain minute timing. To be able to do this requires a good set up (and both DAWs obviously), but when needed it beats exporting.

MIDI Exports as they are now are limited to 96ppq. I think that's too crude for resolution, at least of you record MIDI from live performances, which I do.

Hm, that is indeed very interesting. I did routing ages ago, I might try it again.
If I may know, what is "ppq"?

I think PPQ or PPQN is "pulses per quarter note". These days I guess it's TPQN: "ticks per quarter note" or something like that. Basically this is a measure of time resolution. So is relative to tempo.

[8E]

I meant that a potentially better way to move MIDI into another DAW is to send it out over the MIDI bus and record the MIDI directly into the other DAW when in sync. This will maintain minute timing. To be able to do this requires a good set up (and both DAWs obviously), but when needed it beats exporting.

MIDI Exports as they are now are limited to 96ppq. I think that's too crude for resolution, at least of you record MIDI from live performances, which I do.

Hm, that is indeed very interesting. I did routing ages ago, I might try it again.
If I may know, what is "ppq"?

I think PPQ or PPQN is "pulses per quarter note". These days I guess it's TPQN: "ticks per quarter note" or something like that. Basically this is a measure of time resolution. So is relative to tempo.

Thank you for the clarification, good to know. I guess that if I plan to improvise "tempo free" than it is better (in the case I will export MIDI clips) to have higher tempo values, doubled, 240 bpm.

[Stromkraft]

Thank you for the clarification, good to know. I guess that if I plan to improvise "tempo free" than it is better (in the case I will export MIDI clips) to have higher tempo values, doubled, 240 bpm.

Well, that was the old trick back in the days of limited sequencer resolution. But in Live this makes for a world of hurt as you typically need to make use of all time related info in the GUI and the related concepts. If you export I think you just have to accept the 96 TPQN resolution limit and live with it. If this is a problem depends on your needs of exact timing.

[8E]

If you export I think you just have to accept the 96 TPQN resolution limit and live with it. If this is a problem depends on your needs of exact timing.

Is that one dotted 128-th?
I think it will be sufficient. I am working exclusively with music that will be notated and performed, so no so high resolution is needed.
But good to know that these limits exist.

[broc]

If you export I think you just have to accept the 96 TPQN resolution limit and live with it. If this is a problem depends on your needs of exact timing.

Is that one dotted 128-th?
I think it will be sufficient. I am working exclusively with music that will be notated and performed, so no so high resolution is needed.
But good to know that these limits exist.

96 ticks per quarter note are 384 ticks per 4/4 bar, so the resolution is 1/384 note.

[ecuk]

If you export I think you just have to accept the 96 TPQN resolution limit and live with it. If this is a problem depends on your needs of exact timing.

Is that one dotted 128-th?
I think it will be sufficient. I am working exclusively with music that will be notated and performed, so no so high resolution is needed.
But good to know that these limits exist.

96 ticks per quarter note are 384 ticks per 4/4 bar, so the resolution is 1/384 note.

Because notes are traditionally powers of two, I believe this should be called a dotted 1/512 note.

[8E]

96 ticks per quarter note are 384 ticks per 4/4 bar, so the resolution is 1/384 note.

Because notes are traditionally powers of two, I believe this should be called a dotted 1/512 note.

Oh,yes, that is right. Sorry for confusion.

[ippidippi]

i literally just figured it out. When you extend the beginning of your MIDI clip to a new start point, you are extending into the negative markers (you can observe this in the piano-roll. When the clip is selected, press the hotkey ctrl+J, which will set the 0 marker at the beginning of the newly extended start point.

[Johnnyboy555]

Hey so i dont know if you're still having this problem but the velocity on my midi was turned down and all over the place. I control-a'd and made all my velocity match. Then i turned it up about halfway and after i rendered it everything was working. After everything was turned up a little bit it seemed that the midi was better rendered cause it was louder. I hope this helps.