Macbook Santa Rosa XP / Realtek HDA
Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 7:53 am
This post is addressed to anyone who can help using the Realtek High Definition Drivers in XP or who uses a Santa Rosa MBP with Live in Xp via bootcamp.
i have just upgraded my original 2.0gh core duo to a new 2.4gh santa rosa Macbook Pro. Although the performance from Live in OSX has improved... I cannot get the same performance from this machine as my last.
I predominately used XP via bootcamp on my last machine as I was able to achieve stable performance at a buffer of 64 samples using the internal sound card with asio4all (freeware). This was much faster than the minimum 256 samples I was getting from OSX and still faster than the ~100 I'm getting now.
Now that I have upgraded to a Santa Rosa MBP, performance in XP is horrible. When I press on the test tone in live, the performance meter jumps straight to 50% (irrespective of the sample rate) and I cannot get it below 800 samples without the audio glitching (even when using asio4all).
On the XP side the most noticeable change to the MBP is the sound card driver. The Intel HDA (sound card) was previously driven by Sigmatel but now it has changed to Realtek. I have tried to force the MBP to install the old driver but the device will not function correctly with it.
I am mostly interested in the difference between Sigmatel High Definition Audio and Realtek High Definition Audio drivers. I'm lead to believe there is a problem with Realtek's drivers from reading the following post at the asio4all forum:
http://mtippach.proboards40.com/index.c ... 1117561217
Are there Live users out there getting good performance from Live (i.e. low latency/sample rate) using the Realtek HDA driver in XP? Has anyone got it working at 64 samples with asio4all?
Has anyone successfully replaced the realtek driver with a better working alternative.
Obviously I could get around this by using an external interface but I don't think I should have too. Also, I am well aware of the benefits of both operating systems and am not looking for a mac v windows debate.
Thanks in advance for any info you can give me.
i have just upgraded my original 2.0gh core duo to a new 2.4gh santa rosa Macbook Pro. Although the performance from Live in OSX has improved... I cannot get the same performance from this machine as my last.
I predominately used XP via bootcamp on my last machine as I was able to achieve stable performance at a buffer of 64 samples using the internal sound card with asio4all (freeware). This was much faster than the minimum 256 samples I was getting from OSX and still faster than the ~100 I'm getting now.
Now that I have upgraded to a Santa Rosa MBP, performance in XP is horrible. When I press on the test tone in live, the performance meter jumps straight to 50% (irrespective of the sample rate) and I cannot get it below 800 samples without the audio glitching (even when using asio4all).
On the XP side the most noticeable change to the MBP is the sound card driver. The Intel HDA (sound card) was previously driven by Sigmatel but now it has changed to Realtek. I have tried to force the MBP to install the old driver but the device will not function correctly with it.
I am mostly interested in the difference between Sigmatel High Definition Audio and Realtek High Definition Audio drivers. I'm lead to believe there is a problem with Realtek's drivers from reading the following post at the asio4all forum:
http://mtippach.proboards40.com/index.c ... 1117561217
Are there Live users out there getting good performance from Live (i.e. low latency/sample rate) using the Realtek HDA driver in XP? Has anyone got it working at 64 samples with asio4all?
Has anyone successfully replaced the realtek driver with a better working alternative.
Obviously I could get around this by using an external interface but I don't think I should have too. Also, I am well aware of the benefits of both operating systems and am not looking for a mac v windows debate.
Thanks in advance for any info you can give me.