Page 1 of 1

Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Sun Feb 25, 2018 8:58 pm
by Nokatus
When engaging fullscreen mode, there still isn't any way to access the standard window menus on the GUI? File, Edit, Create, View, Options... At least in Windows I can't find anything. Currently it's not working even with the alt-shortcuts of the individual menus like in earlier versions, which makes me believe the menu objects are being removed completely while in fullscreen mode?

An option to keep the menu strip visible (or at the very least, keep menus accessible through Alt-F, Alt-E, Alt-C... like when in windowed mode) would make fullscreen mode all around more usable.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 7:13 am
by Stromkraft
Nokatus wrote:When engaging fullscreen mode, there still isn't any way to access the standard window menus? File, Edit, Create, View, Options... At least in Windows I can't find anything.
Really? So what happens if you bring the mouse pointer to the top of the screen? Nothing? Have you tried another display resolution? Sometimes the screen can be outside of the display borders because of some size/resolution mismatch.

At least on macOS the menu bar drops down when you bring the mouse up there. I assume Ableton are using the native APIs for full screen. How do other apps work in Windows (10 is it?) with full screen?

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 10:07 am
by Nokatus
Stromkraft wrote:Really? So what happens if you bring the mouse pointer to the top of the screen? Nothing? Have you tried another display resolution? Sometimes the screen can be outside of the display borders because of some size/resolution mismatch.
Yeah, nothing ;)

There has never been a menu there, in fullscreen mode, on the Windows version.

In other apps, it varies how it's done, some have the menu visible up there in fullscreen mode (like Reaper), others have an area where you can click or hover for the menu. At the very least, the alt-shortcuts for menu entries usually always work. Pressing alt once and letting go will make the menu appear in a lot of software that doesn't default to showing it, for example, that's one very standard way of showing the menu strip. Works even in the likes of Firefox where I'm typing this now, hah (just made sure by tapping alt). [Correction: Firefox has the menu hidden these days, and I was actually in the "Maximized" window mode; alt works when showing the menu in that mode, just like in Windowed mode. But in fullscreen (F11) it actually doesn't xD]

There's no way in Live now. At least I haven't found one? It would be great if I'm just missing something here. But at the moment it seems not even the alt-shortcuts for specific menus work (alt-f, alt-e, etc..) so there's no way to access the menus at all. As you can imagine, it can make using the fullscreen mode rather an odd experience.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 10:21 am
by Nokatus
In the manual, it says "When in Full Screen Mode on OS X version 10.9 or higher, Live’s menus will appear when moving your mouse pointer to the top of the screen." But nothing on the Windows version... :)

I just made sure, the alt-f, alt-e (and so on) keys work in Live 8 when in fullscreen mode, so I'm not imagining things, haha. They bring up the relevant open menus (never showing the actual menu strip), and you can also navigate to the adjacent ones with arrow keys after showing one. In Live 10, as far as I can see, there's no way.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 8:09 pm
by Stromkraft
Nokatus wrote:In the manual, it says "When in Full Screen Mode on OS X version 10.9 or higher, Live’s menus will appear when moving your mouse pointer to the top of the screen." But nothing on the Windows version... :)

I just made sure, the alt-f, alt-e (and so on) keys work in Live 8 when in fullscreen mode, so I'm not imagining things, haha. They bring up the relevant open menus (never showing the actual menu strip), and you can also navigate to the adjacent ones with arrow keys after showing one. In Live 10, as far as I can see, there's no way.
This is Live 9 I assume? Have you tried Live 10? I know there were some windows-specific updates regarding high resolution displays and it would be odd to implement that and leave out full screen, if that wasn't available before.

I fail to see why the usual Windows APIs for full screen — that I'd assume are available and in use by many applications with full screen functionality — couldn't be used, but I'm no Windows developer.

I'd assume someone have posted about this years ago. I don't remember reading it though.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 8:26 pm
by Nokatus
Stromkraft wrote:This is Live 9 I assume? Have you tried Live 10?
Live 10. This wasn't this big of a problem before, as the menus themselves were accessible through alt-f etc, even if the menu bar itself wasn't visible. But now in Live 10 there's no way of getting into them, as far as I can see. And the only mention in the manual about those menus when in fullscreen is for Macs.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 8:36 pm
by Nokatus
It seems it has been posted about pretty much always, though. Like, well over a decade.

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=71312
viewtopic.php?f=3&t=41832
https://www.reddit.com/r/ableton/commen ... ble_is_it/

And right now in Live 10 none of that seems to work (even though it would also be very cool to be able to toggle the menu visible somewhere, while in fullscreen.)

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2018 8:43 pm
by Nokatus
Someone has asked about this in Live 10 previously, too, it seems: viewtopic.php?f=1&t=229400

So I gather it's not just happening over here.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Tue Feb 27, 2018 7:55 pm
by Stromkraft
This is a very sad state of affairs indeed. I had no idea full screen would pose a difficult problem for Ableton to solve in the standard Windows way. Maybe it has something to do with Qt that I think Live uses, or at least used in 9, I'm not sure. I've had a couple of odd bugs with it in macOS, but nothing major.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Tue Feb 27, 2018 10:37 pm
by H20nly
weak.

what about just pressing "alt" by itself? that usually takes you to the first menu option (in most cases File)?

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Tue Feb 27, 2018 11:48 pm
by Nokatus
Nah, doesn't work. Like I pondered above, that's one of the standard ways to bring up the menu itself, when it's hidden in a Windows application, but nope.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2018 8:03 am
by Nokatus
No mention of this in the recent beta release notes so far, at least. Just thinking out loud here, I think the alt-shortcuts not working (and thereby making it impossible to enter the menus in any way while in fullscreen mode) is actually a bug? Not that it's a high prio thing at present or anything.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2019 3:35 pm
by Nokatus
Bump, almost a year later. Just feels silly having to disable full screen mode just to use a menu item.

Re: Access standard menus (File, Edit..) when in fullscreen

Posted: Sun Mar 17, 2019 7:26 am
by Idonotlikebroccoli
On Windows 10, I used to be able to press alt+f to access the file menu in full screen, but now it doesn't work. Please fix! :/