..., grand tour.)Ok. So if I instead find one of the numerous threads on Live colors/theming in the main production subforum and reply linking to the new tool, instead of making a new thread, that might be an okay way to draw more attention to the tool in the production forum? Or will all such threads be moved to the Lounge from now on?[jur] wrote:The original topic is in the Tips&tricks forum. Seems the right place to me.
Tarekith wrote:it just comes down to personal preference on where a mod feels something should be placed to make it easier to find in the future. Personally I think anything having to do directly with Live could be in the Music and Production forum true, but at the same time a skin editor technically really doesn't have anything directly related to music or audio production.
No. To be honest, it just felt really weird and randomTarekith wrote:Is it really that big of a deal?
Angstrom wrote:Tarekith wrote:it just comes down to personal preference on where a mod feels something should be placed to make it easier to find in the future. Personally I think anything having to do directly with Live could be in the Music and Production forum true, but at the same time a skin editor technically really doesn't have anything directly related to music or audio production.
To make it easier to find? If I was looking for a skin editor for this DAW I doubt I look in the lounge "anything not related to audio or music production". The Lounge has traditionally for stupid talk about anything unrelated to Live, to music, or to music making. Good TV shows, Net Neutrality, Cat farts, that sort of thing. It seems this has changed as its now full of threads about Push, Live 10 and Live 10 skin editors. It's odd.
Does it matter?
You can of course move, warn, ban. Thats fine. Ableton pay the bills and they have empower you the moderators to move the counters of mere players on the board with no real care for the game. The moderators can indulge in whims to move the mere users contributions around. Thats fine. The dealer is empowered to handle the cards. If the dealer makes a mistake and brushes it off, what then of the game's structure. The players are no longer players but mere disconnected bystanders.
There is no community, just words without value for moderators to shuffle on a whim. What does it matter?
It depends how you feel about community, inclusiveness, respect, and how users might perceive certain actions.
But hey, shuffle the deck. One dealer likes it here, the other there, lets move your stuff around because its ours. What does it matter?
. I hadn't noticed this change, seldom checking out The Lounge, and I figured that a Live 10 theme editor isn't at all Lounge material. First I thought the thread was just gone, I had to google it to find it here, actually, hahah. But it seems these days The Lounge is also for all kinds of production related stuff I presumed it wasn't for.See here, quoted from this thread we're in right now, so that I won't have to repeat myself too much:[jur] wrote:The topic isn't in the Lounge but in the tips&tricks. Why does it feel inappropriate?!
We're not moving stuff around just for the sake of doing something. There's so many threads, we're trying to keep the things a bit tied up. We're open to debate our choices, that's actually what is happening here.
There's also a search function...
Nokatus wrote:Just so that this doesn't get buried in the tips and tricks section (it's much too nice for that) ...
Again, "this" in the line immediately above this one as in this thread we are writing in nowNokatus wrote:(This was originally in the main music production / audio / related subforum, just to let more people know of this nice utility. Now noticed it got moved over here without explanation.)
, not the one in Tips & Tricks. [Edit: at the time of writing this edit, this thread is now ALSO in Tips & Tricks, hah! Quantum teleportation.]
[jur] wrote:The topic isn't in the Lounge but in the tips&tricks. Why does it feel inappropriate?!
We're not moving stuff around just for the sake of doing something.
when I commented this thread was in the lounge. It is now back in the Tips and Tricks section where the poster posted it.Tarekith wrote: The OP posted this in the Tips & Tricks forum even (I moved it to the lounge ...)
Once more: this thread was at The Lounge after I first posted it into Music and Audio Production. That was the surprise move. Then it got moved from The Lounge to Tips & Tricks, where it also currently sits as of writing this. It's not "back" in the Tips and Tricks section, as it never left there, was not posted there, and was never there before this point. The other thread, the one where Lawrence posted his editing tool as a reply to a general question on Live 10 theme editing, has been in the Tips & Tricks section this whole time, never visiting The Lounge, unlike this remarkably agile and mobile cousin thread you are visiting right now.Angstrom wrote:when I commented this thread was in the lounge. It is now back in the Tips and Tricks section where the poster posted it.