You know little or nothing about electronic music composition in that case. I guess we have all gathered that already though. I was not talking about Max for Live, I was talking about Max/MSP. So now you have added OSC into the mix? This is an example of what I am trying to get through to you. Midi is NOT the be all and end all. OSC is great too as it allows communication to non-midi devices, but still not sample accurate. But then again you said it in the post - you simply do not understand what I was trying to tell you - nor did you ask pertinent questions to even try to understand. That's all - no more. Please do not respond to this or quote me again. I have had enough.9V wrote:Well, yes. But this is OT. My answer (complexity) was because the user Trevox linked autechre music as an example of "complicated music made without MIDI" (or something like that... i did not understand really what he meant... he talked about max for live: but max for live, as far as i know, sends messages, like MIDI/OSC, not audio signals). He said it is "complicated", i don't think it is. Frank Zappa music is very complex. Autechre are nice, but quite simple.
You still have not answered my questions either. Given the amount of "cherry picked" replies you make, I think that says it all. You really don't know what you are talking about but refuse to give in.