But conversely "physics may defy your ear". Are we sure that when we analyze, that we are capable of discerning all the factors required to give a true result?AceLuby wrote:I read this as 'I flipped a coin and guessed right 10/12 times, then my friend did and guessed right 9/12 times. We're pros!'abluesky wrote:I was involved in a double blind test between Logic 9 and Protolols 8, using top of the line conversion in a professional studio built for film and TV scoring.
No plugins were used. Just listened to the same track - interleaved stereo file - through the two different programs going through the same IO.
I was able to identify which file was Protools and which was Logic 10 out of 12 times.
Another who took the same test did so 9 out of 12 times.
Rendering out the same file in both Protools and Logic resulted in null.
Go figure.
The null test shows they are the same waves coming from the speakers. It's math. If they are the same waves they are the same. Period. Your ears do not defy physics, I'm sorry.
Yesterday we thought the world was flat and that the atom was the smallest form of matter.