A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Share what you’d like to see added to Ableton Live.
The Landwhale
Posts: 293
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 11:28 pm
Location: United States
Contact:

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by The Landwhale » Sun May 27, 2012 6:00 pm

gibson_ewok wrote:
If you don't mind me asking Mr. Bill, when you were building up your Facebook following, did you post links to your stuff on other people's pages and/or group pages, etc.? I haven't done this yet out of fear as being seen as spam, so I just post in a handful of forums here and there. It works slowly and people keep finding me, but I feel like there's a lot more I could be doing to spread the word without being a spammy prick.
I did some of that, but not much. Basically if someone adds you to a group that's related to sound or something like that, and everyone posts links to their tunes in there everyday, then that's fair game I guess, and sometimes I post in there (but generally I find it's not even effective). I've slowly culled out things that I've found to be almost not effective, such as posting on forums all the time (you might get 50 or 100 plays max from a GOOD forum, where everyone's heaps involved). I don't understand why people are posting the links to their tracks on every other entry out there, how many people do you think will honestly listen to it just because you posted it on another entry? I'm a firm believer of promotion not being about quantity, but quality, which is exactly why I haven't posted my link on anyone else's entry. First of all it's rude, but secondly, no one's going to listen to it that way anyway.

I released a lot of free music, and did a lot of Ableton tutorials all for free, so a lot of people found me that way in the early stages, again playing a lot of gigs (in the start I played a gig almost every week for free, which actually cost me money).

Also, getting affiliated with labels can be a good thing, even if you are releasing things for free, and making proper personal connections with these people, for instance, like if you have good friends that run decent sized labels that have hardcore followers that will listen to anything that label tells them too, then sometimes you can reach out to those friends and get them to post about your stuff also (no point getting just anyone to post about it, you want to target the correct crowd otherwise they just don't get interested and won't become a fan anyway).

Ektoplazm was a big one for me. I did a few releases through there which all got around 10,000 downloads, which helped a lot when it came to sorting out international tours. Also, collaborating with a lot of people, and doing remixes for people, that gets that whole cross-promotional thing going which helps a bit, too. Especially in Australia, where at the moment everyone is remixing everyone else's tracks, it's really helping build the scene a lot.

Also, mailers. Like I just released some stuff through BeatPort (about a week after my Beat The Clock entry) and I got the label (Adapted Records) to attach the link for my track to their mail out which was initially just going to inform people about my Cerebellum Serenade release on BeatPort, it was also made very clear on that mail out that it was a free track if they voted, also with the voting/giving the track away for free system, I made sure to make it very clear that I was just going on an honesty based system, so if people voted, they just had to tell me that they voted and I would give them the track for free without any solid proof that they actually had. I think that kind of built a small level of mutual respect which people also like I think.

Anyway, you just have to be creative with promotion I think, figure out new ways to contact people, and new ways to deal with getting your music to them. Free music is a good one to begin with, Ektoplazm is worth checking out, also BandCamp. I also put a new track on SoundCloud on almost a weekly basis (I don't hold on to any tunes for too long), I think it's important to keep a constant buzz going and keep people interested.

There's plenty of ways to go about it, you just have to get in contact with the right people, and aim your music at the correct audiences to build up a true fan base that actually cares about what you're doing, as I said before it's pointless having 50,000 Facebook and SoundCloud followers that just don't listen to your music or come to your gigs, and you can tell exactly when someones bought their fans, they'll have like 10 or 20,000 followers, but their statuses on Facebook will get like 5 likes and 5 comments, then someone will have 3 or 4,000 true fans, and they'll get 100's of comments and likes and much more plays on SoundCloud etc..

Anyway, hope that helps.

Cheers,
Bill.
Thanks for taking the time respond thoroughly. A lot of truth and good ideas there, very cool of you to share! Will definitely help me out along the way. :)
I agree with the spamming and overblown numbers games, it's pretty silly. Good luck with the contest man, if you win it will be well deserved.

COSM
Posts: 588
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 7:34 am
Location: Christchurch, New Zealand
Contact:

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by COSM » Mon May 28, 2012 4:30 am

I would just like to chip in and say I hope that Soundcloud keep an eye on irregular traffic with this, I for one have close friends who actively purchase likes with real money on the black market. I don't approve of this, but I've seen it happen with with my own eyes, and it's easy.

Here's just one quick search from just one website http://fiverr.com/gigs/search?query=soundcloud&x=0&y=0

:arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow:

I will neW now deliver SoundCloud Plays at least 4200 Plays up to 5 SoundCloud tracks for $5
I am the SoundCloud Specialist.Want to skyrocket... (by cellfishfun )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will add you 2k plays and 500 downloads at SoundCloud song for $5
Hello, i'm working with websites like soundcloud... (by playsprovider )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will add 200 Amazing favourites or followers Soundcloud for your Tracks and Start Getting More Fan for $5
Cheap and best only on Fiverr ! I will add 200 favourites... (by youtube_com )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give you 3 quick tips on how to get more plays on Soundcloud for $5
I am the soundcloud master! I have over 100,000... (by darkandstormy )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

Express
I will give your Soundcloud track 250+ downloads within in 24 hours for $5
Choose one or more Soundcloud tracks that you wish... (by laszlomag )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will send you 250 Soundcloud plays fast gig for $5
I will give you 250 plays to the soundcloud track... (by nunoz1978 )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will increase your soundcloud plays 2000 plays within 24 hours with no account access for $5
We will deliver 2000 fast guaranteed soundcloud... (by badgehelp )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will get you 100 real SoundCloud followers for $5
Get 100 real SoundCloud followers on your SoundCloud... (by jeffhowell )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give you 1000 soundcloud downloads in 24 hours for $5
I will give you 1000 soundcloud downloads within... (by socialmarketeer )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will send you 250 Soundcloud download fast gig for $5
I will send you in one day 250 Download on your... (by nunoz1978 )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will deliver 50 followers and over 500 plays to your soundcloud track for $5
You will get 50 followers and more than 500 plays... (by sk8tavou )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will add 100 followers soundcloud to your channel and tweet your tracks on twitter for $5
?Soundcloud is a social networking site for music... (by a_soundcloud )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will send 150 downloads and 500 plays your soundcloud track for $5
You will get 150 downloads and more than 500 plays... (by sk8tavou )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will increase 1000 plays on your soundcloud track in 1 day super FAST for $5
You will get 1000 plays to your soundcloud track... (by sk8tavou )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will download your soundcloud track 500 times to increase your stats super FAST for $5
You will get +500 downloads to your soundcloud track... (by sk8tavou )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will increase soundcloud plays by 200 for $5
I will give you 200 plays to the soundcloud track you want. Plays will be from real people... (by tygetmoney09 )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will add 300+ SoundCloud Profile Views To Your Profile for $5
?? I Will add 300+ SoundCloud Profile Views To Your... (by facebooklord )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will provide 40 followers on SoundCloud only for $5
I can give you 40 followers on SoundCloud.Moreover... (by jenelia )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give you 5,000 plays and 1,000 downloads on Soundcloud for $5
Give me the URL of a track you have on Soundcloud... (by nickerous )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will deliver you 150+ Soundcloud plays on your track for $5
?Best SOUNDCLOUD supplier on Fiverr? Fast delivery... (by pipelin )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give you 1000 soundcloud downloads in 24 hours for $5
I will give you 1000 soundcloud downloads within... (by magicmedia )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give you 200 Real Soundcloud Views and 3 tweets daily for 7 days for $5
I have good gig for singers, songwriters, DJs and... (by rajpak )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will review your SOUNDCLOUD music for 1 year from 12 separate accounts for $5
?~Charity Gig~? 100% profits go to my Hope for Haiti... (by charityhills )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

Express
I will follow 1000 SoundCloud targeted users for $5
Get SoundCloud followers for cheap: I will follow... (by jeffhowell )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

Express
I will show You How To Get Your Track Lots of Plays and Followers on Soundcloud for $5
I will show you how to get lots of plays of your... (by chivvy )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will like, comment, share your SOUNDCLOUD music and advertise it to 95,000 Twitter followers to get... for $5
?~Charity Gig~? 100% profits go to my Hope for Haiti... (by charityhills )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give 300+ Real FaceBook subscribes/Youtube likes/Pinterest followers/SoundCloud views or any combination... for $5
I will give 300+ Real FaceBook subscribes/Youtube... (by xanderu )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will you 4000 soundcloud plays for $5
4000 soundcloud plays in 24 hours, you can order this give up to 5 times per song but please... (by socialmarketeer )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will give you 6000 soundcloud plays in 24 hours for $5
6000 soundcloud plays in 24 hours, you can order... (by magicmedia )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

I will ? deliver at least 4500 SoundCloud play and Split any way you like on up to 10 songs for $5
I can deliver from 500 to 50,000 or more plays... (by cellfishfun )
Read moreCollect Share order now!

:arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow: :arrow:
Image

COSM
Posts: 588
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 7:34 am
Location: Christchurch, New Zealand
Contact:

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by COSM » Mon May 28, 2012 4:34 am

Oh and just for the record, yes Bill is one of my good friends, no he is not one of the people purchasing likes.
Image

erikomic
Posts: 190
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:36 am

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by erikomic » Mon May 28, 2012 9:32 am

Ah, thank you Cosm for sharing with us this.
I'm glad I started the topic.

If the cheating issue is well-known. The most likely it is they (ableton & soundcloud) are going to sort out irregularities.

The sad part of this cheating is that we will actually never know how many of the "would-be cheaters" have been ripped off their money by those adds... ?
Is it sad ? MmmmH. :lol:

ShenShenDrax
Posts: 15
Joined: Fri Dec 01, 2006 11:04 pm
Location: Brisbane

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by ShenShenDrax » Mon May 28, 2012 10:33 am

I agree that the purpose of the contest is to promote ableton and soundcloud. But they might see it as in their interests to have a contest that doesn't showcase how quickly soundcloud can descend into a spammy quagmire.

erikomic
Posts: 190
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:36 am

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by erikomic » Mon May 28, 2012 10:46 am

100% agree with shen shen

needaname
Posts: 95
Joined: Sat May 08, 2010 2:49 pm

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by needaname » Mon May 28, 2012 11:07 am

I'm totally agreed with you guys.

I have been listening to some tracks in the competition that imho are far better (both on musical and technical level) than "Give Some Get Some", and I believe the only reason why they're not at the 2nd or 3rd place is that this voting system is just bugged.

By the way, I'm obviously going to share mine with you too: http://contest.ableton.com/tracks/1205
Good "luck" people! =)

cpyatak
Posts: 381
Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 10:44 pm
Location: Vermont

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by cpyatak » Mon May 28, 2012 3:42 pm

The big issue I have with the spamming is when it's spam.

I have no problem with someone who has obviously listened to my track and commented posting their entry number. A plus 1 in my messages does not translate into a plus 1 for the person commenting. But it's pretty easy to tell when someone has listened or not.

Often (though not always), I try to listen to the track on Soundcloud so I can post my comments to their track instead of the Ableton contest entry page, and then link to the contest page to vote. I have not been above posting my track number in my comments, but again, I think it's usually clear that I have listened to the track I'm commenting on. I don't think that's spam.

I've gained followers on soundcloud, and started following other contestants on Soundcloud because of this competition, which has been a lot of fun. I'm excited to have new people from all over the world listening to the music I make and giving me their honest input on it. I enjoy listening to their music and giving them my feedback. All in all, for some of us I think this has been a really good, legit community builder.

As for the competition and voting et al, yeah it's flawed. But I've already gotten more out of this competition than I ever hoped for.

There's another thread viewtopic.php?f=1&t=180426 where folks are posting and listening and giving some real feedback, and there seems to be a good supportive vibe there. That said, this is definitely an important topic of conversation here. I'm confident Ableton will take notice of how things have progressed in this competition... but I'm a hopeless optimist! :D

Cheers all!

beschulz
Posts: 3
Joined: Wed Dec 08, 2010 11:06 pm

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by beschulz » Tue May 29, 2012 8:28 am

Hey all,

just want to clarify: I like Mr. Bill's tune - not my style, but very good production - he deserves to be on top!

Also: there's currently a guy spamming. He's telling, that he wrote a script, that gives you the rank. He'll give you your rank, if you vote for his track. THAT GUY IS NOT ME!

If you're interested in you rank (and if ableton does not intervenes), drop me a line (I also have a script).

Cheers to all
-- Benjamin

cpyatak
Posts: 381
Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 10:44 pm
Location: Vermont

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by cpyatak » Tue May 29, 2012 2:05 pm

beschulz wrote:Hey all,

just want to clarify: I like Mr. Bill's tune - not my style, but very good production - he deserves to be on top!

Also: there's currently a guy spamming. He's telling, that he wrote a script, that gives you the rank. He'll give you your rank, if you vote for his track. THAT GUY IS NOT ME!

If you're interested in you rank (and if ableton does not intervenes), drop me a line (I also have a script).

Cheers to all
-- Benjamin
Yeah I just got that piece of spam too. Jeez. At least it's slightly more creative.

I think I'd like to know my rank at the end of voting. Do you think Ableton will announce that?

erikomic
Posts: 190
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:36 am

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by erikomic » Tue May 29, 2012 3:38 pm

there are around 10 tracks by pages >

so if the actual last track is http://contest.ableton.com/tracks/1897
mine is http://contest.ableton.com/tracks/1098

(1897 - 1098) / 10 = 79.8

it should be on the 79th page (counting from last)
for some reason it is a few pages before. page 77 (at the time being)
I think there are some tracks that were never submitted to the end because of technical matters so some numbers don't exist.
There i can see I got 17 votes. I don't know my rank. But I must be in what we call "the rest of the pack" lol.

MMMh. Come-on guys make an effort ! :lol:

vido
Posts: 239
Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 8:39 pm
Location: Oslo, Norway
Contact:

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by vido » Tue May 29, 2012 5:59 pm

I really like those constraints. Especially time-constraints..! I've only submitted to one other contest though.
Agree that Ableton should use a dedicated jury.





Anyway: heres a portion of SPAM for you:

http://contest.ableton.com/tracks/1893
Collab with Jeremy Blake of Red Means Recording:

Blake and Axe; "All The Light I Do Not See"
Spotify: https://goo.gl/MR8Wjr
Tidal: https://goo.gl/s35W33
Google Play: https://goo.gl/HQ1g7E
Amazon: https://goo.gl/cx5dUL

Not the usual stuff.

needaname
Posts: 95
Joined: Sat May 08, 2010 2:49 pm

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by needaname » Wed May 30, 2012 8:03 am

cpyatak wrote:
beschulz wrote:Hey all,

just want to clarify: I like Mr. Bill's tune - not my style, but very good production - he deserves to be on top!

Also: there's currently a guy spamming. He's telling, that he wrote a script, that gives you the rank. He'll give you your rank, if you vote for his track. THAT GUY IS NOT ME!

If you're interested in you rank (and if ableton does not intervenes), drop me a line (I also have a script).

Cheers to all
-- Benjamin
Yeah I just got that piece of spam too. Jeez. At least it's slightly more creative.

I think I'd like to know my rank at the end of voting. Do you think Ableton will announce that?
Got it too, that's the most ridicolous way to have votes. IMHO!

pencilrocket
Posts: 1718
Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 10:46 am

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by pencilrocket » Thu May 31, 2012 10:53 am

I estimeted this situation from the annoucement of it...
Fortunately Abe isn't so stupid that they forget to add this rule.
But there actually is a jury: "The prize winners will be selected from the top 25 tracks by M83, Junior Boys, Nosaj Thing plus the Ableton and SoundCloud contest committees."

Ableton_David
Posts: 1766
Joined: Fri Aug 20, 2010 7:31 pm
Location: Ableton
Contact:

Re: A beat the clock competition with a Jury !

Post by Ableton_David » Thu May 31, 2012 1:20 pm

Hi everyone - I'd like to address some of the concerns here.

Regarding spam - a certain amount of this is inevitable with any competition. There's a difficult line to draw between active self-promotion across different networks, and going overkill. If you're looking for sincere feedback on a track, then it's best to send it to people that you trust, or communities that might be interested in giving you some tips. Otherwise, there are nearly 2,000 entries - it's hard to expect deep and sincere feedback, unsolicited, with such a large pool of entries.

Voting in the Beat the Clock is limited to one vote per track per person. In cases where we can positively identify that an entrant has obtained votes through illegitimate means, we will take appropriate actions and the entrant risks being disqualified. Please leave it to us, however, to identify these cases. I know some things might look suspicious on the surface, but without proof it can quickly turn in to an online shouting match - and no one needs another one of those. Try to focus instead on promoting your own work, and checking out some of the other incredible entries.

Lastly, some clarification about the judging process. The 25 entries with the most votes will be judged by M83, Junior Boys and Nosaj Thing. Their top 10 picks will win prizes. As such, even if someone did manage to get his/her track into the top 25 through shady tactics, it's not likely to make it to the top 10.

Of course, no competition is fool-proof, and no voting system is perfect. We have strived to make Beat the Clock as even and fair as possible - for example, through adding a random list of tracks that appears on the home page every time you refresh it. Thanks again to everyone who has entered - and remember that you can keep voting until June 15!

Post Reply