Step sequencer and rec quantized notes should respect swing

[TheEntireRobot]

I don't know if this is a Live issue or a Push issue, but seeing as I'm experiencing it when using Push, I thought I'd post it here:

When I have Swing set to a non-zero value and program drum notes in a clip, I'd like the notes entered into the step sequencer to have swing immediately and automatically applied. Right now, they don't have swing automatically applied, even though the notes are correctly quantized to the grid.

Also, if I have Rec Quantize On, any notes that I play are correctly quantized to the division I set in the settings, but swing is not applied.

This means that as I'm programming or playing new notes when Swing is non-zero, those notes' rhythms are incorrect (and sound pretty bad) until I manually press the Quantize button, at which point the swing is applied and they line up correctly.

I think the current behavior should be changed, and that the swing value should always be respected when quantizing notes, whether it's when pressing the Quantize button, programming notes in the clip view grid, or recording notes with Rec Quantize On.

Thoughts?

[Alex1210]

This bugs me too , good idea

[Drumstix]

that's exactly what I thought! I created a max4live device to easily add swing to a clip, to all clips of a track or to all clips in the song. But ran into the same issue. I always have to commit swing to the clips by pressing a button.
Also, the swing amount isn't stored in the live set. That bugs me too. Next time you open the set, swing amount is reset to 0...

btw if you're interested, this is the link to my device: https://maxforlive.com/library/device/9919/swing

[zenkick]

I think the current behavior should be changed, and that the swing value should always be respected when quantizing notes, whether it's when pressing the Quantize button, programming notes in the clip view grid, or recording notes with Rec Quantize On.

Thoughts?

Agree.

Have you posted this on Centercode? If not, please do.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, consider joining the beta program (see pinned posts on this board for details.)

[lmbauer2017]

Yes this sounds like a bug IMO. If the Rec Quantize works, then the swing should work with it as well. Submitting a report now in case OP isn't set up for it.

[lmbauer2017]

FYI: Turns out this is expected behavior in case anyone else stumbles upon this.

https://www.ableton.com/en/push/manual/#quantizing