Preferred file format for DJing
Preferred file format for DJing
Hi!
I plan to use Ableton mainly for DJing, and I heard different things about preferred file formats. A friend of mine told me that Ableton kinda renders (?) a temporary wave file from any compressed type when used, so it's not worth storing my music as mp3s. Since I use a laptop, where file size is crucial (I know I know i know quality is crucial as well) I should know what file type(s) to prefer as a DJ.
( tried to search this Forum, but couldn't find any relevant... If this issue has already been discussed, please drop me a link.)
Thanks in advance
I plan to use Ableton mainly for DJing, and I heard different things about preferred file formats. A friend of mine told me that Ableton kinda renders (?) a temporary wave file from any compressed type when used, so it's not worth storing my music as mp3s. Since I use a laptop, where file size is crucial (I know I know i know quality is crucial as well) I should know what file type(s) to prefer as a DJ.
( tried to search this Forum, but couldn't find any relevant... If this issue has already been discussed, please drop me a link.)
Thanks in advance
true, ableton converts mp3's in waves before it actually uses it. They are in your decoding cache folder, wich you can "cleanup" (remove all non-referenced converted files) in preferences. I recommend you do this regularly if you watch out for you HDD space.
I now convert all mp3's in advance to waves, so I have a clear overview of my files.
I now convert all mp3's in advance to waves, so I have a clear overview of my files.
waves have better quality
http://www.myspace.com/djvakis
http://mix2r.fm/audio/user/221
----------------------------------------
MacBookPro 13" Core 2 Duo 2.26Ghz 2GB
Live 8 -Operator -Sampler
AKAI LPD8-GENELEC 1029A-iPhone runing TouchOSC.
http://mix2r.fm/audio/user/221
----------------------------------------
MacBookPro 13" Core 2 Duo 2.26Ghz 2GB
Live 8 -Operator -Sampler
AKAI LPD8-GENELEC 1029A-iPhone runing TouchOSC.
-
- Posts: 1505
- Joined: Fri Aug 05, 2005 11:51 pm
nixon wrote:
but i hate mp3s and don't see the point of having them at all, a 320kbs file is pretty much the same size as an AIFF or Wave, so why having all those different file types flying around? apples Ipods take full Files, and if i give a friend a tune or take it to a large system for playback, i have quality... all the way!
i only use mp3s if i have to mail someone very quaickly a tune for quick listening / checking. song / arrangement, etc. otherwise for me mp3s are a no go.
NO! not on an ipod, especially not with the original ipod headphones, they suck!can you hear the difference on an ipod??? even at 320??
but i hate mp3s and don't see the point of having them at all, a 320kbs file is pretty much the same size as an AIFF or Wave, so why having all those different file types flying around? apples Ipods take full Files, and if i give a friend a tune or take it to a large system for playback, i have quality... all the way!
i only use mp3s if i have to mail someone very quaickly a tune for quick listening / checking. song / arrangement, etc. otherwise for me mp3s are a no go.
cryptic UK wrote:
i have 3 drives right now, one system and two large audio drives and about to purchase another audio drive. (i do all my back-ups on quality DVDs (tayo yuden or verbatim super AZO) for longtime storage)you guys using aiff or wav how many hard drives do you have because if i had my whole music collection in aiff or wav i would have a ridiculous amount.
my apologies!
despite the non use of any kind of mp3s from my side...
(sorry that i never paid any attention to the actual size of the mp3 file, only to the sound, and here are the short comings)
here are the figures:
i took a 16bit 44.1khz AIFF file with the size of 54.6mb
and converted it with peak5 to a 320kbs 16bit mp3 file size: 12.6mb
if storage is from concern, fine. it's not a subject in my case.
i prefer sound over saved cheap HD space.
cheers
despite the non use of any kind of mp3s from my side...
(sorry that i never paid any attention to the actual size of the mp3 file, only to the sound, and here are the short comings)
here are the figures:
i took a 16bit 44.1khz AIFF file with the size of 54.6mb
and converted it with peak5 to a 320kbs 16bit mp3 file size: 12.6mb
if storage is from concern, fine. it's not a subject in my case.
i prefer sound over saved cheap HD space.
cheers
Stereo 16bit 44.1KHz AIFFs/WAVs are about 10MB/min.
That's over 10,000 stereo track-minutes, or almost 3,500 3-minute stereo tracks on a 100GB drive, which is small by today's standards. Many laptops have even larger internal drives, and small external drives have never been cheaper.
IMO, no need to waste time with MP3s or any other compression scheme and the associated encoding, decoding, and potential quality loss issues.
That's over 10,000 stereo track-minutes, or almost 3,500 3-minute stereo tracks on a 100GB drive, which is small by today's standards. Many laptops have even larger internal drives, and small external drives have never been cheaper.
IMO, no need to waste time with MP3s or any other compression scheme and the associated encoding, decoding, and potential quality loss issues.
Last edited by hambone1 on Tue Jul 18, 2006 2:53 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Since I don't like the idea of playing out with an external drive (seems WAY too risky to me), storage is a big issue. I have a few wavs, from before Live allowed mp3s, but mostly I use mp3s. They're almost all at least 192kbs, with a good number substantially higher. Though I'll be honest - there's a few that are lower (though I don't think anything's lower than 160). But the thing is - nobody can tell the difference. I'm certainly not slagging anyone who wants to be certain that everything's quality; I can understand that. But for the most part, sound quality has much more to do with the system that you're on, and in most clubs, no one's going to notice the difference between 192, 320, and wav.
Though if I were really concerned about quality and space, I'd use flac since Live 6 will be supporting it.
Though if I were really concerned about quality and space, I'd use flac since Live 6 will be supporting it.