Ableton Forum

I tried several things and got your older notes only version kinda working.

It was just kinda spitting out notes unrelated to anything else.

I would troubleshoot it more, but the plogue demo expired after just 3 days...

Have you tried adding compression on the audio before it gets to Bidule?
// C

No, I'm not sure of how to do much in Bidule.

I want to be able to just sing simple monophonic tones and have Live record them to midi.

Would this solution be suitable for that?

If not, I was even thinking of springing for Logic (since you get so much more as well).

I have to do some more testing with Widi and Fiddle~ in PD, but was getting weird results with them as well.

I'll have to try again when the demo gets updated...

always updated, search for "latest" in the forum.

Well I meant the demo.

I actually got some interesting results with Fiddle~ in PD.

There is one output type that constantly outputs at least 43 notes a second in whatever pitch you put in.

The other output puts out one short 'blip' at the attack of each new note.

If there was a way to make the 2nd output type send a constant note for the "gate" time of the current note and send the first output type to optionally constantly adjust pitchbend, I think that PD with Fiddle~ could make a useful tool for free with no overhead.

It's surprising how little information there is about these tools on the internet.

Is anyone interested in looking into this as a free/cross platform audio to midi solution?

Kodama wrote:Well I meant the demo.

I actually got some interesting results with Fiddle~ in PD.

There is one output type that constantly outputs at least 43 notes a second in whatever pitch you put in.

The other output puts out one short 'blip' at the attack of each new note.

If there was a way to make the 2nd output type send a constant note for the "gate" time of the current note and send the first output type to optionally constantly adjust pitchbend, I think that PD with Fiddle~ could make a useful tool for free with no overhead.

It's surprising how little information there is about these tools on the internet.

Is anyone interested in looking into this as a free/cross platform audio to midi solution?

this sounds kind of interesting, but you'd need to have a way to route the audio in/out from pd to live, or use 2 soundcards under windows, or the directx drivers (which have bad latency...). otherwise it *shouldn't* be too difficult... i say shouldn't as i only looked at PD for the first time two days ago so... the help file for fiddle is pretty good though...

You just use an internal audio routing utlity, like SoundFlower or Jack, or asio4all.com.

You set Live's main outputs to 1/2 and send your controlling audio channel to External out 3 (for instance).

Then set PD's input to (the virtual audio routing software's) 3 and output midi information to Midi Yoke or IAC on Mac.

Then make a midi track in Live that receives IAC.

Download the Extended version of PD (http://puredata.info/) and check the help file for for fiddle.

Create and connect an audio input (Adc~ 3) to the first outlet on Fiddle and a makenote > noteout on the back end and you will get the same results.

Kodama wrote:You just use an internal audio routing utlity, like SoundFlower or Jack, or asio4all.com.

how d'you do this with asio4all? have you used jack on windows, and if so did it work well? theres also VAC (http://www.ntonyx.com/vac.htm) for internal routing on pc, but i have no idea what it's like...

Well I'm on Mac now, I guess you would have to use VAC or Jack for Windows...

I'll take another look at the Bidule thingee when they refresh the demo.


In the meanwhile - I've moved discussion about doing this in PD to here:


http://www.ableton.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=75703

Kodama wrote:I'll take another look at the Bidule thingee when they refresh the demo.


In the meanwhile - I've moved discussion about doing this in PD to here:


http://www.ableton.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=75703

i'm having a little look at the bidule stuff as well, and if i can figure anything out in PD i'll let you know. the PD/Max.MSP objects that you use ('fiddle' and 'bonk' respectively?) are based on http://aubio.piem.org/ and theres someone that made a bidule using it (seehttp://www.plogue.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=2556) and i'm seeing if that can be made available...

Cool!

Let me know if you get any results.

I wouldn't mind buying Bidule (or perhaps Max) in the future, but I just want to know that it works first

i gave up on max for now. the interface makes life at lot more difficult for the time being (until v5 comes out, which i think is next month...). PD's obviously the cheapest, but bidule isn't too far behind
it's a shame reaktor can't do this type of stuff... oh well - they'll add proper fft one day i guess.

as it is i can control the frequency of an oscillator using an fft in bidule with a guitar pretty well... i'll have more of a hack around with it when i get a chance, but if this guy comes good with the aubio based stuff it might make life a lot easier. have't had a proper chance to look at the pd option yet, but i dl'd jack for windows and i might put that on tonight and see how we go.

Ya, just check my notes in the other thread and remember that in PD, you put objects, type in their name, and then they come to life, with ins & outs, etc..

Also, you have to set the audio prefs to make sure you are set for at least 4 inputs, etc...

Let us know what happens!