Alright, so here is the question I was gonna hold off on:beatpoet wrote:Don't see a problem, people sell live packs that include racks as it is. People aren't really selling the rack as such they are just effectively selling a rack preset, if the m4l patch uses a Live feature it will not work independent of Live, it would be sold to work inside Live and nowhere else.LOFA wrote:Thanks Bjorn, I thought I remembered reading that somewhere.
What I am curious about now, is to what extent are Max/Live/M4L owners going to be limited from rendering apps with these ableton parts in them for resale. It brings up new questions. I'll have to start a thread some time closer to the release...
If I don't own Live, but I own Max and Max for Live, I will have access to these new "Ableton designed components". So, what is stopping me from selling apps that now include these in them as well? See, it gets a little harder for me to make assumptions.
Right now anything I build in Max I can sell (provided there is a market.) I wonder if I will still be able to render apps with these Live components.
The other question is on the Live end. Since I own both Max and Live, what is stopping me from rendering a patch via Max as an external app, and then just having a customer route it to Live. I wonder if the delay with the Pluggo and rendering vst's for Max 5 is related, because that would be the most obvious method for making M4L items available to non M4L owners.

