Post
by quandry » Thu Aug 04, 2005 10:11 pm
having just watched the two videos (kid beyond and jamie), I got to say that kid beyond TOTALLY smokes Jamie in terms of his beatboxing/vocal abilities, as well as his compositions and musical style. no contest. not that it is or should be, but since both of these vids are mentioned in this thread, and the styles are similar, its hard not to compare. Jamie's act visually is nauseating and self-indulgent, and the hat is just ghey. I watched the Kid movie first, and thought the hand movements were a bit much, but they are tame compared to jamie's activities.
Even so, my main point of this post is while I'm very impressed at kid's style and flow, I feel he must really be selling himself short by not using his hands to control Live. I do live looping with Live too, using instruments, and can't imagine not using the crossfader every song to bring tracks (and groups of tracks) in and out to give the tunes more variation. I also can't imagine not using all three of my midi controllers to have control of track volumes, pans, send knobs, on and off switches and knobs controlling dozens of effects, the crossfader on the DM2, etc. I realize his use of Bomes might get him some mileage, but from watching the video, it doesn't seem like THAT much is happening with any foot pedal press, and clearly with only 12-16 pedals, he is limited in how many commands or strings of commands he has at his feet. I just think that his compositions and performances (all I've seen/heard is this video) could have so much more to them if he used his hands to control the app, with both midi controllers and god forbid the mouse.
I could be wrong, but as a fellow live looper with Live, I just can't imagine not constantly using both hands at all times to give the tunes variation. Its relatively easy to get a bunch of live loops going and stacked on top of each other--takes like one minute, just like in the video. But to have interesting and not repetitive performances is obviously the biggest challenge with looping, and to take your hands out of the equation is crazy. The challenge for me is to take these repeating loops and continually vary the mix, by bringing things in and out, using effects on tracks, sends, and even the master out, hell just using sliders and pans to get relative volumes of the loops in check. Would love to see and hear more of the Kid, but I hope he takes his "hands off" approach and grows into using his hands to create the variation that helps breathe more life into loop-based performances. Dude has serious skills, but if the tunes are always him building up loop on top of loop and not breaking it back down, or taking loops and scrubbing them or effecting them to give them different sounds, it seems like he must just be building heavy sonic walls of loops that can sometimes be too much at once--with so many loops going you start to lose the subtleties and interactions.
Ryan
Dell Studio XPS 8100 Windows 7 64-bit, 10 GB RAM. RME Multiface, Avalon U5 & M5, Distressor, Filter Factory, UC33e, BCR-2000, FCB1010, K-Station, Hr 824 & H120 sub, EZ Bus, V-Drums, DrumKat EZ, basses, guitars, pedals...
http://www.ryan-hughes.net