eat a dick.digitalex wrote:?
Why, man, why?
Why, is an edit to you "flaking out"? Seems to me easier to add to a previous statement than extend the thread.b0unce wrote:
well done - this is only the Nth time you've flaked out.
when i was in school, they told me practice makes perfect, then they said nobody's perfect so i stopped practicing -steven wright
youve got it right on point my boy.knotkranky wrote:Ya don't know it but this is what you dudes are taliking about. It's all connected. At the end, there is a rule for everything.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... eory&hl=en
cheerio.
man, when i left earlier today this topic was at 1 page or just went to 2 pages, when i got back and it was at 5 , i was like 'no way in hell that many people posted about a topic in that little time' i had a feeling it was a fight between b0unce and digitalalex, gut feeling was right, and i trust my gut, which has diahrhea, which meant it was something bad......
oh well,
c'mon guys cant we all just get along?
oh well,
c'mon guys cant we all just get along?
Music might not have rules but it definately has laws.
I like Brian Eno's definition of art as being everything that we do that we dont HAVE to do. We have to move but we don't have to dance, we have to communicate but we don't have to write poetry, etc.
Ok, back to the bitchin.
(and this started out as such a nice little thread)
I like Brian Eno's definition of art as being everything that we do that we dont HAVE to do. We have to move but we don't have to dance, we have to communicate but we don't have to write poetry, etc.
Ok, back to the bitchin.
(and this started out as such a nice little thread)
"That very perceptive of you Mr Stapleton, and rather unexpected... in a G Major"
-
sweetjesus
- Posts: 8803
- Joined: Wed Mar 31, 2004 3:12 pm
- Location: www.fridge.net.au
- Contact:
cage's silence crap is only ever referred to by friends who have no musical training or musical technical skills.
widely referred to as 'music' its widely refertred to as an experiement.
music whether you know the rules / laws or not is still derived from very specific rules.
someone mentioned listening to jazz and not knowing what rules there are... well do you have to know how a car is built to drive it?
does it mean that because you dont know the laws/rules for all the engineering which goes into a car that there are none?
this isnt quite the sound of a tree falling in a forest here...
jazz and all modern music, especially stuff that uses any modern tuning is based on science and nature. http://www.kylegann.com/histune.html#hist3
widely referred to as 'music' its widely refertred to as an experiement.
music whether you know the rules / laws or not is still derived from very specific rules.
someone mentioned listening to jazz and not knowing what rules there are... well do you have to know how a car is built to drive it?
does it mean that because you dont know the laws/rules for all the engineering which goes into a car that there are none?
this isnt quite the sound of a tree falling in a forest here...
jazz and all modern music, especially stuff that uses any modern tuning is based on science and nature. http://www.kylegann.com/histune.html#hist3
-
stale bread
- Posts: 1101
- Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2005 11:09 am
- Location: Los Angeles
Music has No RuLes.It is ALSO widely regarded as an experiment. It's not difficult to understand that because it is regarded as one thing does not mean it is not regarded as another. I don't think it would be famous controversial piece if only idiots were arguing over it. And your car analogy is wrong here. I used jazz as an example to illustrate that you can appreciate something as music even if you don't understand the rules. You are arguing over a point you agree on. Read the thread closely next time. And Bounce, where did I disagree with you? Couldn't resist one last post...going to bed nowsweetjesus wrote:cage's silence crap is only ever referred to by friends who have no musical training or musical technical skills.
widely referred to as 'music' its widely refertred to as an experiement.
music whether you know the rules / laws or not is still derived from very specific rules.
someone mentioned listening to jazz and not knowing what rules there are... well do you have to know how a car is built to drive it?
does it mean that because you dont know the laws/rules for all the engineering which goes into a car that there are none?
this isnt quite the sound of a tree falling in a forest here...
jazz and all modern music, especially stuff that uses any modern tuning is based on science and nature.
when i was in school, they told me practice makes perfect, then they said nobody's perfect so i stopped practicing -steven wright