I think in most fields a college degree is overrated and overly expensive. I’ve been reading a lot lately that real world self-motivated experience and certification programs are just as good, if not better. The tech industry is full of people at the top level who dropped out of college and along with the impending college debt implosion I think there is going to be a real “fuck college degrees!” backlash. That doesn’t mean some education isn’t helpful. It means you don’t need to waste time and money becoming “a well-rounded person” with a home mortgage size debt before you even get a job.
Personally I feel the current system is a relic of the past held tightly by those who already went through the system “I did it. So you should too!”. It’s just not making sense anymore when you really step back and look at it. I think certification programs and trade schools are where it should be at.
Agreed, if you can pursue the career of your choice without a typical college degree, then by all means do so. Unfortunately, college is the logical next step for many people coming out of highschool when in reality a lot of people don't need a four year degree for their job of choice.
That being said, being in a university environment as a young person is (imo) a highly valuable experience, beyond what you experience just within a classroom setting. Like you said, self motivated people tend to thrive without the need for a degree program, but many people aren't highly motivated right out of high school. College worked well for me, I got two degrees, had a lot of amazing experiences that I would probably never have the opportunity to do if it weren't for my college career, but it is not for everyone and definitely not a requirement for a prosperous and enjoyable career.
Music production is an excellent example (I think) where a tech-school or certification program is an ideal place to gain the skills necessary to be decent without devoting a large part of your life to a debt-ridden degree system.
The current student loan/debt empire is certainly a backwards-ass system at the moment, and sooner or late more people will start to realize the downfall of the old ways.