Ableton Forum

Is anyone using this combo successfully?
I'm using Max as rewire master, Live as slave (so audio is passed from Live to Max) - this part of the deal works fine.
I want to be able to pass MIDI via rewire from Max to Live and it's not playing ball. Any ideas?

Cheers

good luck.
i'm just learning about Max/msp.
Hope everything goes well with you.

Yeah it's a steeo learning curve.
I used to be able to write code back in the 8 bit days and worked out a very efficeient algorithm to do a bit of midi mapping - turned out as about 4 equations. It then took me 3 whole days to translate it into Max. I did do a lot of reading though.

hi nunrgguy,

unfortunately you can not send midi data from a rewire host to live running as slave. what you can do is sending midi data from live running as master to another slave like reason. you can try a more sophisticated midi routing using something like midijoke (pc only).

kind regards,

matthias

Thanks for the reply - I've been tearing my hair out with that one. Is it something that will be implemented in a future version of Live? - As I understand it the MIDI part of rewire is full duplex, or am I mistaken?

Looks like Yoke it is then.

Hi
I use Max/MSP and Live together, but not with rewire.
The solution is to use midi ports of max :
define your midi input in Live on "from maxmsp 1" and in Max, send your midi data in midi ouput "from max/msp 1"
and you can receive midi from live using "to maxmsp 1" as midi output of live (and input of Max)

Are you using a Mac or PC? - I don't think Max has its own ports on PC

Well, yes i'm using a mac. I'm very surprised that there is no midi ports on Max PC !

You should subscribe and post a msg in the max/msp mailing list :
[email protected]

search and inscription on http://www.cycling74.com/community/index.html

This list is very usefull for all Max/MSP users (for beginners too)

I have never used a mailing list before.
Is it like this ableton forums ???

Or do I just recieve emails ?

cheers

it's a discussion list, but you can perform a search in the complete archive (on the url i gave u)
You can post questions, and others max users (even max /msp creators) will help you, it's a very nice community

if u subscribe, you'll receive all the discussions, then u should create a mailbox or folder for it, so u can search directly in your outlook (or mail app)

here is another url : http://www.idecibel.com/
but it's a french forum

me too, i'm gonna use pure data with live, we'll see...

Here it is - I was correct, Max on PC and Mac are different beasts in certain areas.
from:http://www.synthesisters.com/hypermail/ ... 17988.html

I wouldn't mess with the rewire object. You can send midi messages
> from Max very simply by using any of the MIDI out objects like
> midiformat and midiout, or ctlout to send control changes. Just set
> the midiout (or ctlout) to one of the from MaxMSP ports, then enable
> the MaxMSP ports in Live and set the Remote Control input to the Port
> you selected before. To assign the midi control, click the MIDI button
> in the main window of live, which highlights all of the MIDI
> controllable parameters. Click the parameter you want to control and
> send it the data from max. It will show a set of numbers that
> correspond to the midi data you sent. Continue to click and assign
> however many inputs you want, then deselect the MIDI button to turn off
> assign mode, and play to your heart's content.
>
> FYI, if you are using a PC, you will have to install an
> interapplication MIDI app like MIDIYoke or Maple virtual MIDI to give
> you the ports you need.
>

Just installed Yoke on my machine - won't work atm becuase I've now got 10 s.a.m. devices installed which is the maximum on XP. So now I@ve got to take the box to bits to remove some hardware (disable doesn't work). GAAAHHHH.