Ableton Forum

yiggap wrote: ↑

Fri Oct 09, 2020 4:58 pm

trtzbass wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 16, 2020 2:07 am

ARA, midi export and vocal comping plz!
Then I can ditch Logic

YES but I don't think they're working on it ...... this thread is old now. I have to go to Logic to do all my vocal recordings / editiing. And come back to Ableton. So stupid ...

But let us keep this thread alive, not to loose hope! To me, it is obvious that this is currently the most important piece missing in this otherwise great DAW!

+1 ARA 2, Vocal Comping, integrated pitch correction and MPE support as well.

+1000

I just can't believe they skipped adding it again in 11. Comping is terrific! But c'mon...

Definitely upvote for ARA2, Melodyne without is no fun!

This is definitely a must have. Comping AND ARA2 support and things will be perfect (BTW, New Protools update coming out today includes Melodyne now within PT...So Basically Live is the only remaining daw that doesn't supports ARA yet...well...)

Runenlyd wrote: ↑

Fri Nov 13, 2020 10:03 am

This is definitely a must have. Comping AND ARA2 support and things will be perfect (BTW, New Protools update coming out today includes Melodyne now within PT...So Basically Live is the only remaining daw that doesn't supports ARA yet...well...)

Included melodyne is awesome.
UP

>opens ableton
>ah the vocal is suck
>opens reaper to tuning the vocal
>repeat

>opens ableton
>ah the vocal is suck
>opens reaper to tuning the vocal
>repeat

this is a big reason i use studio one more than i should.

Hopefully this is one of the features Ableton is saying isn't ready yet which might mean it will be a minor release for v11. Implementing comping, I think Ableton gets the point that people want to edit vocals and recorded audio tracks better and Melodyne really helps here and kind of makes it where they don't have to focus on developing these tools in house which would be alot of work.

jlgrimes wrote: ↑

Sun Nov 22, 2020 5:54 pm

Hopefully this is one of the features Ableton is saying isn't ready yet which might mean it will be a minor release for v11. Implementing comping, I think Ableton gets the point that people want to edit vocals and recorded audio tracks better and Melodyne really helps here and kind of makes it where they don't have to focus on developing these tools in house which would be alot of work.

Let us hope, but ARA2, is kind of a major thing, though. I really hope it isn't planned instead as something to implement in the next major release, to get people to update. I do think, that would be kind of a gamble, as 3 or so more years without it, could mean that people start looking elsewhere. I do hope they do something similar to the Chord-track of Studio One, when they do implement it, as that would be brilliant feature in a DAW, that many like for how they can start with a sketch to build a full song, then being able to mess with the key of the song or change chords on samples quickly, could potentially speed up the process (even if at the end, some of it might be re-recorded to the new key/chord, once the sketching part of the song is done).


On my wishlist, would be some kind of Comp grid functionality, so a ableton controller could be used to switch takes, and jump on the timeline, possibly with scaleable timeline resolution to be able to go in to the really fine details.

Any mention of this for 11?

Didn't see anything so wishful thinking I suppose...

+1000 and for the same reasons than everybody else. Comping rulz but we need all the vocal editing tools (ARA2, or a native good pitch and alignment vocal tool like both Melodyne and Vocalign...you have the choice, Ableton ! )

I desperately need this too. Now I have to go back and forth between Ableton and Reaper.