Push3 : can't observe a control without grabbing it ?

[chapelier fou]

I wanted to observe the Button Matrix. It's not possible if not grabbed ?

[[jur]]

Hey Louis,

This is fixed in the current beta... but it did bring another problem: once something have been grabbed, it won't be observable as a new set is loaded, and Push needs to be rebooted.

[chapelier fou]

And I suppose [closebang] don't work with M4L...
But as far as I know, if something has changed in the set, there must be a dialog box opening, maybe we can use this to know if we're closing a set, and then release all controls ?

[[jur]]

And I suppose [closebang] don't work with M4L...

It doesn't, indeed...

But as far as I know, if something has changed in the set, there must be a dialog box opening, maybe we can use this to know if we're closing a set, and then release all controls ?

Peeddrroo tried to use this method, but to no avail afaik.

[chapelier fou]

Then we can only hope for the future.
Although I’m a bit tired of hoping.

[chapelier fou]

Tried on the latest beta. I can indeed observe the Button_Matrix without grabbing it. But if I reload the set, the observer will not work.
It seems that I need to restart Live.

[[jur]]

It seems that I need to restart Live.

Live, or Push. Both resets the thing.

[[jur]]

Then we can only hope for the future.
Although I’m a bit tired of hoping.

Since this issue almost kills the M4L+Push duo, I have hope that it'll be tackled asap.

[chapelier fou]

It's not been fixed yet, has it ? Seriously, wtf ??

[[jur]]

It's been fixed since then.
Is it not working for you?

[chapelier fou]

take this device (observes the clip matrix). Save it as a device and save a set.
Reload the set it doesn't work anymore.
Close live. Re-open live. It works.

<pre><code>
----------begin_max5_patcher----------
1899.3oc2ZsziaaCD9r8uBAgdb6BQ8zt2Z64BTfdLnvP1lqMSkkDjnbbxh7e
u7gdKQww1xdS6k0IjThy227hyH99xElaStfyMM9EiOYrXw6KWrPLDefEk++E
lmBurKJLWrLyS377vCXyWjyQwWnhw2FFenZv3hSIEzHLU7HnxQI6EKLY6m+Y
6pUJWF8qoXoLXZZ72kSkFR2cjDeXSFdGUNqyqVuX3uh+2.wessd0p9AX6JIt
ZSs4i88kK4+4k6DZj8FVfg15aCZHOOAf7sE+r9Uu4Fcw3uvjuAfiZr0HZbzY
ODcNqTBOoAfNXZ4JvmmODXhlQk3tvnHiCX5lcIwzrjHieqfRSh27GgzLxEvp
WmfaT+hPbDibD1sHO6mm4qD4YgauSniPN2H1sDNtHjP2iBbedXOMKIEmQ+pw
4vnBLbsL5VQp.aNR.GDL+.cV7hsuWuXowbYL3GfSrBTlwDWbamX3H1WsBEZL
KjPotF8zTpQjy3WS1liyNiyfCUm6FpNNhvSAVZfZ4f4gmw62v1a16YSHkETY
KSOkWB3RDuvbCySLmjSww6v0FFRpZdILtb.Opl+c4piVIxj4E7eLpJU3FkVj
ebCiL.SVN2U1O20ByJ+o4JT62CyvuG27FIBelSOIwsV8ByvzzVCun0ivYjOm
HdQqdodHRrbH+5gxvmI8esr2aFCMTFTJxDX07huqYyqIYONKtfznk35lRQRn
EhCYImRCkJRgxpZ5F9wSPLHKAy36J76bW0hgXZ4CQI69GrPWXUMHK4VLINMC
miiogzRYud5832BKhnadiEsLm7MooD20dj4eqTBGcRNFDh+ulQBipAvgLx9j
XtPzQSvGtZ63mrUdhm1fQrh3vzQdXoughIyYfrHeaXFWQsMB2x0hYamjD0cp
5mKB+Fsb5TRbbOVjljpdxLxgiS7raSXSdZp2sXl7MEwxY2vrIna3wA5tN1gz
JcU695uDFSNERwThTEXaUOINNjAzi46XYBi5fW4LmGYl8La7c3uP1SOJ1n1F
CrkSRqLhLq0x6IGv4ztiQCOj2cjb5WkjdqgJ1V5CughOkFwPQ2Ev7NXA4xOl
7k7xEVYn0l.ZpOssOc63dcFuW7OYfpZG1AQ4rZMyHUnpJhVfHflSfs77dU+s
1DWUTMYbgjSmXNrcHCw9GuGeoUjjpP9KpB3eKDfPDTiez33G09IF+Thcv5HT
jqHmne.TFx5ihg5jhr+4pipOWs5ieopG..NElxLlN9xhkbZcFa6IMvdNLRw2
HF908CYDNwYbNwyRuE0KM+R3JePFXHYBFW4gzmjhreNTz2hLxvGtZqF2f62r
oLrj7fDqc0a07jnjbbjwexNroy0yJdfra.xL1ABiEezOLFKxZZEH5poF24xf
w1U7SYyG+QfVRMXm4N62+qqlTrslKRorIcHa.FKn9uvl5V5R.JqeQUML8d7w
pkQQ8LpqoQecMppsoS8M.pwoWcNHj0Zo8lkxJcTVsCfJdfT0i1Je.V8yDU.A
qJHMUBosZHsUDoopH8UFos5H.UHAoJoqoRoIpVRaESSW0zzUNMc0SSVAkppn
FuRJEUSAphJfUUMdkU8izzOJ9f4mrG7CCoenLPbu4iHw3cIExC6a2aRk0pnr
yTSD5uimmhP+dVxica0blRm9NspyI1IuX2bi2K6NHWo5O.f9DlC+zNZYuQOn
kxDnxLmtST7xDEv7.YQc1nLrbzn7iKrIuHimaH23mPOFiVu4wls7Kp4Wdbkf
+yXzJ5WOmxuC50QM8BHjvKibhPMzLx1poW15o4mgUc+V7bkgNCzxS8qFWGEs
VcOelruOS06GE8+4ARqCZc3zsOb.utxDZ9FaOqqgwP+ekwVCfwV48rXrohP1
8T773UZNKk.I70MMclmTjsqxsqLGgwPvwNpIkDWW+ympC3wW6MonuU4y4JjO
9wLd5BHO7FXIz6iP.uJJb0GgDx0aHnR35OJIDLGp2Ooq6s7q1W+45G4C2OrM
MUMPHMZWRTRVW7zEz3K79YjWW13xwEqV+61sfQ2cJne+mtopTODkrMLpW4jp
JjcJwTGI99RXTXGtVMA1gydNctb3kP4J9paZZdIvt4hr.2M2a2NZ76nhRlt4
i+OHYYC4Ol6eKUv.2908iKovim+oU3KDjEvsHDV.DBtx8gID7OulgM.of2e7
1A+lUovM.HWX+HEBOfBQkz9XjBWnRg2CTJrs.5gr9QKDf8PdTRABpTTo4dLR
APgvSMUzDIEPJ05q.mxjoMXQQZzpst72pj5PuKiW08JZ5yYz+LF8DkoHh2WN
MMTySiSB0Xelurpzijb4GUX76foyv6foum1KuMucM8tCESbqLk8yR2kUu803
Vrht4wkDQeugR5X5TlpRQ3zjtb.iCci78.rSsqG3l2ImU.1IGzbsSnmA64D.
g87mCLgfZQbu6jMH8TWfmjsW987st+sFAgNQOCPh513gFThtu81GBAuZNTkN
PLZlA5DAAR1yge.BDjlCxCAZqFw4VF7u2MUguK8tYJ8tQJCuIJpuAJ8u4Ih7
7ptoIK+9x+EPOERg1
-----------end_max5_patcher-----------
</code></pre>

[chapelier fou]

Same thing with any control I want to observe.
First time, it works.
Then if I reload the set, it doesn't work. I have to either restart live or Push.

[chapelier fou]

@[jur] Does it work on your side ??

[Rivanni]

Not [jur] here, but it also doesn't work for me.
The observer only sends bangs after you reload the device or project.
After a restart of Live or Push, the values are sent again.
Seems to be a general issue with the observer.

[chapelier fou]

Thanks for confirming.
Isn't it crazy that no one else reports it ? I mean, it's basic functionality if you do anything custom with Push...