PLB wrote:FaX-01 wrote:
This is "Hard Techno" we're talking about not fucking Zen Buddism :roll: .
Seriously people .......
And if I might add why does decent electronic music have to be so 'rythmn centric' I swear it's like uber beat facism or something.
A great melody with clever use of counterpoint and a great atmosphere can be just as "transendental" as anything else out there.
Seems to me we lost the beauty in the melody a LONG LONG time ago I'm afraid.
(And that's not just a dig at electronic muso's either) :(.
you're missing out on something that you will never understand until you experience it.
I am a classically trained pianist and i understand what you are saying about melody and counterpoint and all that, but there is an ecstasy you can only get from rhythmic music and being a part of a crowd that is moving to it.
I am not missing out on something I will never understand IMHO.
I've been doing electronic music composition since 89' and played bass guitar as a teenager from 80-86 .
I have been part of many a crowd back in the day that was moving and grooving too various forms of rythmic music.
I would still say the effect is more physically 'euphoric' than it is 'consciousness expanding' and far more hedonistic than it is cerebral.
I just feel we place too much emphasis on the almighty rythmn in electronic music in general.
There are alot of other compositional tools and devices that can be deployed other than the rythmic too elevate ones state of consciousness for example.
I would just like to see a better balance between the rythmic/hypnotic and the melodic and harmonic in alot of electronic composition.
To me the beat isn't the be all and end all of the music I write.
Then again I'm not aiming my compositions at the "club' or "dancefloor" brigade.
Everything is there for the taking when it comes to composing in my humble opinion.
For example I'd like to see more advanced midi effects and processing tools in LIVE.
Tools for generating canon , dual cannon , harmonic , inharmonic , mirrored and reversed counterpoint would be more than welcome additions to Live's Midi effects.
As would a good midi harmonizer , a complex midi delay device with control over number of repeats , feedback gate time per repeat , note feedback + & - polarity per repeat etc as well as more refined midi timestretching tools and a midi recycle device that works of predifined and custom user definable templates for generating variations on midi data in realtime that stayed in key with your main project etc etc ...
Also things like sample crossfading in arranger view.
The option to have spline based envelope curves with clip envelopes and proper rex file support via an Ableton REX player.
Also FFT based spectrum processing FX.
Also an experimental Impulse respones device would be great.
Groove template analysis for stealing grooves from beat loops and being able to apply them as quantize templates on custom beats , with analysis options for more melodic based sample data.
Midi step sequencers would be great also with rotate , gate shift , fold back , bidirectional playing templates and intricate clock divisor features would be welcome also.
I understand the importance of rythmn within a composition and good syncopation also and how it can effect a crowd on a dancefloor.
I just don't view it as the main crux or be all and end all of composition with electronic instruments in general.
I suppose the point I'm making is if the world is your oyster and music is your world why limit yourself to only beat-centric musical composition.
I'd like to see less DJ based enhancements in LIVE 6 and more musically viable compositional and structuring tools that can help all LIVE users expand their sonic and compositional pallete into areas they may not have initially thought of exploring.
To my mind for electronic music to really develop as an artform we need to get away from grid/beatlocked structures and stifling genre specific mindsets.
We also need tools that enable us to escape more conventional pattern/loop based paradigms and enbale to explore more freeform and expressive compositional avenues.
Follow Actions is definately a feature in the right direction for starters in LIVE.
Sorry for taking this a bit off topic.
The beat has it's place and the groove is a powerful tool.
I just don't feel it should be the foundation on which most popular forms of electronic music are based that's all.