Better Sounding: Live 7, Daft Punk, Mac or PC?

mikemc · Post by **mikemc** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 10:00 pm

just curious...

[edit] I'd say Live 7, because i can make it sound however i like.

GUY SMILEY · Post by **GUY SMILEY** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 10:35 pm

live punk

Winston · Post by **Winston** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 10:36 pm

You heard the new Mac Punk 7 Pro? It's the best one.

mohler · Post by **mohler** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 10:50 pm

Winston wrote:You heard the new Mac Punk 7 Pro? It's the best one.

I'll take it over 7 daft PCs

Robert Henke · Post by **Robert Henke** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 11:15 pm

As I said before, there is no audible difference between Live 7 and a forum topic. It really comes down to the user. If the user is using it right, it sounds right. Some users sound better then others in user defined conditions if other users are present at the same time. Or if no other users make use of the same user base. This is a classical multi user scenario and it is supported by the forum and by Live since a long time. Long term users might be able to comment on that. Users need to understand that from a user perspective, a user is just a user and we all sound the same more or less.
Everything else is just useless.

Hope that helps.
Robert

sparklepuff · Post by **sparklepuff** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 11:22 pm

Robert Henke wrote:As I said before, there is no audible difference between Live 7 and a forum topic. It really comes down to the user. If the user is using it right, it sounds right. Some users sound better then others in user defined conditions if other users are present at the same time. Or if no other users make use of the same user base. This is a classical multi user scenario and it is supported by the forum and by Live since a long time. Long term users might be able to comment on that. Users need to understand that from a user perspective, a user is just a user and we all sound the same more or less.
Everything else is just useless.

Hope that helps.
Robert

Tone Deft · Post by **Tone Deft** » Thu Feb 21, 2008 11:24 pm

mikemc · Post by **mikemc** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 4:07 pm

Robert Henke wrote:As I said before, there is no audible difference between Live 7 and a forum topic. It really comes down to the user. If the user is using it right, it sounds right. Some users sound better then others in user defined conditions if other users are present at the same time. Or if no other users make use of the same user base. This is a classical multi user scenario and it is supported by the forum and by Live since a long time. Long term users might be able to comment on that. Users need to understand that from a user perspective, a user is just a user and we all sound the same more or less.
Everything else is just useless.

Hope that helps.
Robert

It's definitely useful, if not helpful. Especially the part about where it's supported by Live since a long time. But are they using Macs?? Or PCs?? And are they Daft users, or just punks??

I'd agree that daft forum posts sound as good as 7 user punk pcs. It could help if someone inverted the phase on a forum post and then done some additive cancellation to show this empirically.

sparklepuff · Post by **sparklepuff** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 4:12 pm

mikemc wrote:
Robert Henke wrote:As I said before, there is no audible difference between Live 7 and a forum topic. It really comes down to the user. If the user is using it right, it sounds right. Some users sound better then others in user defined conditions if other users are present at the same time. Or if no other users make use of the same user base. This is a classical multi user scenario and it is supported by the forum and by Live since a long time. Long term users might be able to comment on that. Users need to understand that from a user perspective, a user is just a user and we all sound the same more or less.
Everything else is just useless.

Hope that helps.
Robert
It's definitely useful, if not helpful. Especially the part about where it's supported by Live since a long time. But are they using Macs?? Or PCs?? And are they Daft users, or just punks??

I'd agree that daft forum posts sound as good as 7 user punk pcs. It could help if someone inverted the phase on a forum post and then done some additive cancellation to show this empirically.

And for you:

logic_user99 · Post by **logic_user99** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 4:36 pm

Chocolate beef-crackers.

creature · Post by **creature** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 4:56 pm

I might get the Daft Mac Pro Live Suite 9.a

I hear you can do trance with it

Steve

SubFunk · Post by **SubFunk** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 5:32 pm

Robert Henke wrote:As I said before, there is no audible difference between Live 7 and a forum topic. It really comes down to the user. If the user is using it right, it sounds right. Some users sound better then others in user defined conditions if other users are present at the same time. Or if no other users make use of the same user base. This is a classical multi user scenario and it is supported by the forum and by Live since a long time. Long term users might be able to comment on that. Users need to understand that from a user perspective, a user is just a user and we all sound the same more or less.
Everything else is just useless.

Hope that helps.
Robert

damn, i was spitting all over my better then other users new daftop live 7 punk sound suite.

pulsoc · Post by **pulsoc** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 6:00 pm

Wow sparklepuff - you pulled that out of your freezer just for a photo-op?

Dj Dreem · Post by **Dj Dreem** » Fri Feb 22, 2008 6:08 pm

sparklepuff wrote:
mikemc wrote:
Robert Henke wrote:As I said before, there is no audible difference between Live 7 and a forum topic. It really comes down to the user. If the user is using it right, it sounds right. Some users sound better then others in user defined conditions if other users are present at the same time. Or if no other users make use of the same user base. This is a classical multi user scenario and it is supported by the forum and by Live since a long time. Long term users might be able to comment on that. Users need to understand that from a user perspective, a user is just a user and we all sound the same more or less.
Everything else is just useless.

Hope that helps.
Robert
It's definitely useful, if not helpful. Especially the part about where it's supported by Live since a long time. But are they using Macs?? Or PCs?? And are they Daft users, or just punks??

I'd agree that daft forum posts sound as good as 7 user punk pcs. It could help if someone inverted the phase on a forum post and then done some additive cancellation to show this empirically.
And for you: