is Israeli response to Palestinians disproportionate?

Discuss music production with Ableton Live.
Post Reply

is Israeli response to Palestinians disproportionate?

yes
87
70%
no
37
30%
 
Total votes: 124

b0unce
Posts: 5379
Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 4:16 pm

Post by b0unce » Mon Dec 29, 2008 6:40 pm

catatonic douchefuck wrote:
b0unce wrote:
douchefuck wrote:Oh you can copy and paste, you are so clever.
Had I merely said "you know, 'only' 16 israelis have actually been killed by qassam rockets fired from gaza since 2001" some douchefuck, probably you, would berate me for not posting a source to verify such claims.

I'm just surprised none of you waffling fairies thought to bring up such a significant number.
So I guess you are discounting the human bombs walking the streets. What's the kill ratio on those guys?

eh ?
from the first page of this thread - which I obviously need to remind you poses a question on disproportionate military responses:
"GAZA CITY (CNN) -- Israeli airstrikes pounded Hamas-ruled Gaza on Saturday, killing at least 225 and injuring 400,in what Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak said was a response to escalating rocket attacks against Israel. "


Jesus H Christ, get with the program.
spreader of butter

bosonHavoc
Posts: 1936
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2007 8:34 am
Location: Austin, Texas
Contact:

Post by bosonHavoc » Mon Dec 29, 2008 6:59 pm

if everyone would put down the guns and pray for peace they would have it.

DGA
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun May 07, 2006 11:21 pm

Post by DGA » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:01 pm

condra wrote:Over the years, I think the ratio of Israeli lives to Palestinian lives has averaged around 1:400.

Let's hope Israel never want revenge for past events. In that case, 1200,000000 Germans better watch out.
germany is home to about 80 million people

DGA
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun May 07, 2006 11:21 pm

Post by DGA » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:11 pm

bosonHavoc wrote:if everyone would put down the guns and pray for peace they would have it.
until a bulldozer comes to clear the way for more illegal israeli settlements.

beats me
Posts: 23319
Joined: Fri Mar 30, 2007 6:39 pm

Post by beats me » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:20 pm

b0unce wrote:
catatonic douchefuck wrote:
b0unce wrote: Had I merely said "you know, 'only' 16 israelis have actually been killed by qassam rockets fired from gaza since 2001" some douchefuck, probably you, would berate me for not posting a source to verify such claims.

I'm just surprised none of you waffling fairies thought to bring up such a significant number.
So I guess you are discounting the human bombs walking the streets. What's the kill ratio on those guys?

eh ?
from the first page of this thread - which I obviously need to remind you poses a question on disproportionate military responses:
"GAZA CITY (CNN) -- Israeli airstrikes pounded Hamas-ruled Gaza on Saturday, killing at least 225 and injuring 400,in what Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak said was a response to escalating rocket attacks against Israel. "


Jesus H Christ, get with the program.
I'm with the program but I doubt either side is forgetting the violence and body count of the past, as if that was then and this is the new quarterly team building goal or some shit.

It's not Israel's fault that their aim sucks. You think they're sitting on their back porches drinking lemonade going "good effort, but try a little to the left next time and then we'll volley back"?

3dot...
Posts: 9996
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 11:10 pm

Post by 3dot... » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:31 pm

what bOunce doesn't understand... is the concept of Martyrs in Islam...

Hamas had been firing rockets over the border on Israeli towns...

the fact that their kill ratio is weak is because they are being watched and CANNOT aim properly...
they are using mortars and very primitive rockets...
they have a very short time to set up... and fire...
before being shot down by the army on the border...
so they fire.... and pray to Allah that it hits...
they aim at schools... shopping malls....kindergarten ...whatever...
they usually miss...
fortunately for Israel ... 'only' 16 were killed by this specific method...
some were injured and mutilated....(also children)
so they're out of the statistic... right?
no suicide bombers lately... because the borders with Gaza are closed...
also...
the thing is not how many were killed... it's that these people are working tax paying citizens...
and they have been living in the shadows of these rockets...
imagine having to go to run for shelter every day you go to school/work...
for years !
could you send your kid to school ...
knowing that there's a good chance that they will not return ? or be mutilated?
and if so... ? for how long....

what did they think would happen... ???!!!!

answer :EXACTLY WHAT'S HAPPENING NOW !
you see... the Hammas has no REAL agenda except hatred...
that's their only card...
so if Israel should strike the poor Gazans....
all the worlds eyes would be back on it...
and that would be proof that Israel is evil...

right ?!
WRONG !

Hamas has made the Palestinians in Gaza .... into martyrs....
heroes in their own minds...
whether they like it or not...
they are using them to leverage terms for a 'truce' (which they never honor...)
it's what they want... it's what they say they want = WAR

why aren't Arab states helping ?
why did the Egyptians and the Saudi's schedule a meeting of the Arab league only on Friday 2/1/09 ?
it's all a game.... and we (civilians) are the puppets....

I cannot stomach the words MARTYR...
or INFIDEL anymore... I've fucking had enough...



they have been given fair warning...
(Israel withdrew under fire
(again... seen as weakness by our neighbours)

had shown restraint....

restraint time is over now....

I'm so sorry that all this is happening.... I and many other citizens here...
I had always dreamt there will be peace here when I was older...
my parents dreamt that there will be peace when I would turn 18....
I'm almost 30...

there will never be peace.... not in my life probly....
even if there was no state of Israel... war here would continue...

Palestinians are fighting for their right to be a state...
we are fighting for our rights to LIVE ....

I will leave this region in the next year as there is no hope in living here...
I would take my family with... but they would not want to leave...
so I guess I will be fearing for their lives....for as long as I live...
that's what terror means to do...

about the bigotry...
it's all around... and is definitely not one sided coin ....
Last edited by 3dot... on Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image

Machinesworking
Posts: 11551
Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2004 9:30 pm
Location: Seattle

Post by Machinesworking » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:32 pm

3dot... wrote:
Machinesworking wrote:
3dot... wrote: ...that is a grouse simplification of things... also... what's white ?
I tried talking to you about these things in PM, and you ran out of air. Sorry man, you're so involved in defending Israel that you really can't be unbiased about this, shit, you live in the winning side of the conflict?
I feel for you, and respect your fears, yet I also think your government, like mine, is as responsible for creating the environment that nurtures terrorists as the terrorists themselves.
I don't remember 'running out of air'....
You dropped the conversation when we were going over the fact that England promised the Palestinians the same land they promised the jewish people.
and I'm not on a 'winning' side...
there are no winners...
If death count is any indicator, your country is pulverizing the enemy. and always has been.
only people that want to live in peace...
no one is enjoying this....
I think the religious leaders on both sides, and Israeli settlers in the Gaza strip prove otherwise. They seem to be enjoying it.
and naturally I'm involved... being born and raised here...
although I do not think I'm biased...
only trying to explain what the feelings are around here...
This is maybe unintentionally disingenuous, at the least your oversimplifying ;) the simple FACT that being born into a conflict like you have will color your perspective, no matter what. Kudos for adding your voice to the discussion though, regardless of your rather silly appraisal of your bias.
My position for instance doesn't come from any family bias, I know and have no close Palestinian or even arab friends, and many jewish friends, of those only half agree that Israel is out of line most of the time, and needs to alter it's policies on a grand scale if this animosity is to ever subside.
you guys get fired up ONLY when Israel's army acts....
and do not consider the time 'in between' in which Israeli citizens are bullied on a regular basis for 60+ years now...
on it's various borders... and within them...
Like I've said over and over again, the fact that Israel was created on a broken promise to the Palestinians has NEVER been dealt with. That alone is the starting point of all this, yet it's tactically ignored by Israel and the rest of the western worlds governments
funny you should talk about Lebanon...
the situation in Lebanon was only slightly different....
the govenment there was too weak to take responsibility for Hezbolla firing continously over the north border...
while Israel has no real beef with Lebanon....

currently most efforts and funds that were used by Hezbollah have been routed to Gaza ...
I too... hate this situation... it's pretty hopeless...

I sure hope my generation...
will succeed in ending our conflicts with the Arab world...
It will change when you and your government recognize your own culpability in the creation of terrorists, otherwise 60+ more years of aggression is in your future.
and it has very little to do with OUR government...
Israel only responds to threats to it's existance...

if there were peaceful people on the other side... then this war would not have been...

I love it. Kudos to you for being so honest in your obvious bigotry. Though I'm sure you'll come back with some attempt at covering up what you just said here! ;)
It's amazing how little responsibility you're willing to take for your governments ruthless oppression of people, all in the name of "stopping terrorism" by land grabbing, setting up permanent fortresses in foreign countries, bulldozing houses, 'smart' bombing suspected terrorist areas, which are always in some bastards back yard, shooting and killling kids who throw rocks..... the list goes on.
It's the same here in the states, a conflict will be seen as successful if the body count on our side is low, regardless of the other side. This of course NEVER works, and is to me the primary reason for fundamentalist movements worldwide. To resist an enemy that outguns you, it seems the common reaction is to dig firmly into your ethnicity and religion.
Which seems to be the case with Israel as well, they can't justify this if they only include Palestinians, but if they consider the entirety of the arab world as their enemy, then the aggressor is HUGE! 8O Then a common enemy with enough power to fear is found.

BTW Israelis for the most part are white, western cultured people in an area of brown people that have been colonized and subjugated by western powers for hundreds of years now. This is why I will always think that England didn't give up Israel to the jewish people as a free piece of property. England has a history of divide and conquer, and setting a minority up with all the leverage in an area with a hostile majority. Sound familiar?

condra
Posts: 2755
Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2007 2:03 pm
Location: Dublin

Post by condra » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:38 pm

DGA wrote:
condra wrote:Over the years, I think the ratio of Israeli lives to Palestinian lives has averaged around 1:400.

Let's hope Israel never want revenge for past events. In that case, 1200,000000 Germans better watch out.
germany is home to about 80 million people
no shit.

Chang
Posts: 286
Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2008 9:38 pm

Post by Chang » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:49 pm

3dot... wrote:
Machinesworking wrote:
3dot... wrote: ...that is a grouse simplification of things... also... what's white ?
I tried talking to you about these things in PM, and you ran out of air. Sorry man, you're so involved in defending Israel that you really can't be unbiased about this, shit, you live in the winning side of the conflict?
I feel for you, and respect your fears, yet I also think your government, like mine, is as responsible for creating the environment that nurtures terrorists as the terrorists themselves.
I sure hope my generation...
will succeed in ending our conflicts with the Arab world...
and it has very little to do with OUR government...
Israel only responds to threats to it's existance...

if there were peaceful people on the other side... then this war would not have been...

Yes I agree with you totally. I see on Bbc Cnn that israelis completely pulled out of gaza. Even sent in israeli military to take israeli settlers who did not want to leave gaza and took them out of their homes by force. Then after israel occupation of gaza is over and every single israeli is out, Hamas says ok, we can all have peace now. But thats a bullshit lie. Hamas only used the peace agreement time to smuggle in the weapons they're launching now. Totally unprovoked. Hamas say all jews out of Gaza, only then will we have peace! So Israel gets every single jew out of gaza. Wheres the Peace? The peace is wait a few weeks to get a few truckloads of missiles in from iran and then start launching them into Israel. And Hamas is committing a double war crime. one because they target civilians obviously, and two because they use their own civilians as human shields on known military targets that they know will probably be hit by israeli air force. And after all Hamas lies about cease fire, continued suicide bombings and begin launching missiles into Israel during cease fire gaza peace agreement this entire mess is somehow 100 % Israel fault? Because they are the occupier?

Everyone in the US and Canada is occupier of native american land. Britain occupied many countries with colonies. South africa is occupied land. Australia is occupied continent. Could go on forever. I don't see anyone complain about those places. And what is ironic is that all of those places mentioned are occupied by people who were not there 3000 years ago. The jews were in Israel 3000 years ago. The jews named the area Israel after revolting against the Roman empire and were later slaughtered all over israel during the crusades defending their homes. So imo if anyone of the multitude of current global occupiers has an argument about staying on land, and a bond to the land, israel has a better argument than anyone else.

3dot...
Posts: 9996
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 11:10 pm

Post by 3dot... » Mon Dec 29, 2008 7:49 pm

check your facts machinesnotworking
Image

beats me
Posts: 23319
Joined: Fri Mar 30, 2007 6:39 pm

Post by beats me » Mon Dec 29, 2008 8:00 pm

3dot - Why doesn't your family want to leave? I question why any sane person would want to stay there given the chance to leave.

3dot...
Posts: 9996
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 11:10 pm

Post by 3dot... » Mon Dec 29, 2008 8:03 pm

the Jewish people have been thrown out of this region
once...
by the greek...
twice...
by the Romans...

they have always come back here

it is our only home... and we originate HERE....

all of our history and heritage are here...

it has been proven...

that is mostly why we were 'given' this country...

what you see now is ancient hatred acting up....

and is the same reason the Jews were persecuted everywhere they go...

they have kept their faith....
for thousands of years while past empires also tried to 'divide' and conquer...
jews kept their faith wherever they went...

"by the rivers of Babylon ... where we sat down... and then we wept... when we remembered Zion..."

there are people from all over the world living here...

because it is their home...

it sure as hell ain't because it's a cushy place....
Image

3dot...
Posts: 9996
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 11:10 pm

Post by 3dot... » Mon Dec 29, 2008 8:08 pm

my mom is Yemen... my dad Hungarian...
my parents ,myself and my brother have a Hungarian citizenship...
so I am a European citizen...

when the peacetalks with Arafat began I was in high school...
and the peace treaty with former enemy 'Jordan'
I had held the hope for peace (illusion?) for very long...

but I can't take it any more...
need to come up for some Oxygen...
Image

b0unce
Posts: 5379
Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 4:16 pm

Post by b0unce » Mon Dec 29, 2008 8:09 pm

we have entered....the bible zone.
<theremin music in the background>
spreader of butter

3dot...
Posts: 9996
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 11:10 pm

Post by 3dot... » Mon Dec 29, 2008 8:14 pm

b0unce wrote:we have entered....the bible zone.
<theremin music in the background>
:lol:

yeah...it's sad... I know...
Image

Post Reply