madlab wrote:bkg2018 wrote:Hi all, I use Live 8, and recently buyed the nanoKONTROL. And pad and keys, but this is not relevant here. At first I thought that would be cool but very fast, it became obvious that it won't.
- Am I supposed to be a MIDI wizard programmer? I mean it's 2010 here, and reading the nano documentation, supposedly I know all about midi channels, CC control codes and all that? Come on ... I'm a casual musician, I buyed a cool modern Mac not to worry about technical problems, I buyed the cool Ableton Live 8 suite because it's only about music, and then I buy a simple USB controller and they tell me about rocket-science stuff coming right from the 80's and the Korg Kontrol Editor is terrifying, hardly mentioning any musical term... is this some kind of joke? How did that creepy thing get out of lab?
- Say I simply want the slider from tracks 1 to 8 to match the volume in tracks 1 to 8 of Live, okay I know how to do that manually but I have to create my tracks first, knowing exactly where I will use audio and midi tracks, this is a nonsense as opposed to Ableton Live spirit. Worse, I have to do the assignments for each new set. My Axiom 49 is easy to use: I have a preset which always makes sliders match tracks 1 to 8, whatever I do with tracks. Why is there no such preset available on nanoKontrol?
- I tried to get Myralfur's stuff which sounds like the answer to my questions but I 'm locked somewhere : where do I put these files ? Do I REALLY need to open the Live 8 application container to put something in there, meaning I will have to do it again at next update?
All in all I find the hardware cool enough but it looks like there is absolutely no Ableton Live support, and in fact the user software issue has been totally ignored, and this makes the product a hell to use.
If some of you peoples have answers to these kind of questions I'm asking myself I'd be glad to hear your point of view, and the tricks you use, because right know I feel I will sell all this korg nanoThing on ebay, loosing money but thinking about the APC or something more musician oriented...
Understanding the midi protocol is a priority for all us guys intending to have real time control over multiple parameters. That's not rocket science because for now, there's nothing to replace midi...
I understand the need to control parameters in real time and the reasons why MIDI has been designed in the first place 25 years ago or so. I'm also fine with the fact that peoples like to push it to the limits and need full control over MIDI messages.
But understand my point of view:
- on Analog Arturia Experience keyboard, I simply need to turn a knob to play with my LFO in real time.
- if I want to assign a knob to a control in Live, I click on "midi", I click on the control in live, I turn my knob, and I can play.
- on my SH201 Roland, I simply play with any parameter I want, there is a controller for that and I can tell you forget MIDI very easily while playing with lots of controls in realtime.
More generaly I certainly don't NEED to know if it's sending a -127..+127 number for the 21CC on channel 2. This is a job for programmers. I do C++ or Objective C programming all day long and the last thing I want to think about when I plug my nanoKONTROL in my macBook is that 8-bit numbers / 16 channels old stuff. Mind me, I just want to play music. Arturia can give that to me, Ableton can, Roland can, but why Korg can't is a mistery to me
(By the way, Korg nano series doesn't include the traditionnal MIDI implementation chart, so you see they don't even match your desire

...)